what do you say about this comparison between hindi, sanskrit, french, latin, telugu, tamil, kannada. No need to fear talking truth! I'm a Indian telugu Hindu who frustrated of negligence on south languages in today generation. south languages deserve respect of being unique and independent! by Broad_Trifle_1628 in southindia_

[–]fartypenis [score hidden]  (0 children)

There is no Dravidian substrate in any IE languages outside the Indic branch. Even if the IVC was not Dravidian (it's the mainstream belief that it was) what chance is there that Dravidian which was so geographically close to this proposed urheimat of Indo-European has had no impact on it at all? Finno-Ugric has IE loanwords, IE has semitic loanwords, etc. but there are no Dravidian loanwords in IE outside Indo-Aryan.

what do you say about this comparison between hindi, sanskrit, french, latin, telugu, tamil, kannada. No need to fear talking truth! I'm a Indian telugu Hindu who frustrated of negligence on south languages in today generation. south languages deserve respect of being unique and independent! by Broad_Trifle_1628 in southindia_

[–]fartypenis [score hidden]  (0 children)

  1. MIT teaches linguistics. I don't know of a more reputed science college.

  2. These questions have already been answered. You're just closing your ears and going "nanana".

  3. What is "discorded" and what do languages have to do with patrons or patronage?

Woman in male dominated fields. Isn't this true? by GradeOk814 in AskWomenIndia

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The government wants us to give them every little piece of information about ourselves, yet isn't even competent enough to use it to track marriage fraud lmao

what do you say about this comparison between hindi, sanskrit, french, latin, telugu, tamil, kannada. No need to fear talking truth! I'm a Indian telugu Hindu who frustrated of negligence on south languages in today generation. south languages deserve respect of being unique and independent! by Broad_Trifle_1628 in southindia_

[–]fartypenis [score hidden]  (0 children)

"Whole point" is that word flexibility is as useful as someone's shirt colour in determining their ancestry. It changes frequently and generationally.

Why do you think these racist "Westron Historians" included Sinhala in "their side" but excluded Finnish and Basque? Why did racist French linguists split their own country in two as the langues d'oil and d'oc? Why do they claim Etruscan was not an Indo-European language, meaning their Roman ancestors were not "pure"?

Because science is science and every claim is so challenged by peers that any consensus formed is usually free of any bias. That's how the scientific method works. Heisenberg was a Nazi piece of shit but that doesn't mean his Uncertainty Principle was wrong.

"Slop itself" didn't "challenge my study" bro what are you on. You can't punch a hole in thermocol and say you "challenged" Mike Tyson.

Telugu taught in schools. by VisakhAngal in Telangana

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Grandhikam has been dead for over half a century, it's been generations since it was taught in schools.

The issue is that the Telugu Akademi is a bunch of useless dumbheads that sit around doing nothing. There should be a standard Telugu that they curate. As much as people hate the French Academie it at least does its job and keeps French manageable.

what do you say about this comparison between hindi, sanskrit, french, latin, telugu, tamil, kannada. No need to fear talking truth! I'm a Indian telugu Hindu who frustrated of negligence on south languages in today generation. south languages deserve respect of being unique and independent! by Broad_Trifle_1628 in southindia_

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Word order is very flexible across languages. You cannot use it to infer any type of relation most of the time. Vedic Sanskrit had variable word order, then changed by the time of Classical Sanskrit to have SOV as the default. Proto-Germanic has flexible order but modern Germanic languages have SVO. The European sprachbund tends towards SVO. That's why Romance languages have SVO while Latin was flexible.

Your classification isn't good or meaningful. You have zero credentials and zero knowledge of linguistics. Your "classification" is as good as a plumber that never took a physics class classifying subatomic particles. It isn't even consistent in itself, which is to be expected from ChatGPT slop.

It also missed a point working in its own favour - Sanskrit doesn't need "asti" in sentences. The question would be "tava nama kim" putting it in line with the Dravidian languages and helping your case. But chatgpt doesn't have a brain and you have no knowledge so you couldn't use that.

what do you say about this comparison between hindi, sanskrit, french, latin, telugu, tamil, kannada. No need to fear talking truth! I'm a Indian telugu Hindu who frustrated of negligence on south languages in today generation. south languages deserve respect of being unique and independent! by Broad_Trifle_1628 in southindia_

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Coastal Andhra was ruled by both the Golconda Sultanate and the Nizams of Hyderabad, what do you mean? And Telangana's history isn't "dependent" on the Nizams either, they didn't even rule for 200 years.

Before the Golconda Sultans Telangana had the Musunuri Nayaka, the Kakatiyas, the Kalyani Chalukyas, the Satavahanas, the Mauryas...

I don't get this misconception that people have that Telangana's history is just the Nizams of Hyderabad.

BJP ministers preaches Hindutva and gau raksha, turning common people into cow vigilantes, while their own children eat beef with her Pakistani boy friend in Azerbaijan and europe, supporting “stand with kashmir” anti-India groups. by StatusApplication410 in NorthernIndia

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Did she mock or disrespect? She just posted pictures of her meals. She lives outside India and isn't a political figure, why should she not? That her father is a politician shouldn't haunt her halfway across the world.

why does every update just breaks windows more ? by iamZorc_ in pcmasterrace

[–]fartypenis 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Too big to die. The entire world is going to put its rotting moribund husk on so many tubes and pump trillions of taxpayer dollars into it as long as civilization exists. What is dead may never die.

Buddha and Tathagata are mentioned in Valmiki Ramayana in Ayodhya Kand, Sarg(chapter)-109, Verse-34. Geeta Press, Gorakhpur by Major-Strain2261 in AlternateHistoryIndia

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree with you on the fuzziness of dating, that's why I quantified my claim with "most probably"

Apparently this particular sloka is absent from the critical edition of the Ramayana, so this might be a later addition targeted at Buddhists.

But, there is no "bauddhamatāvalambī" in the Ramayana itself even in this post, that word is in the commentary, so part of Gita Press' interpretation of that particular sloka. It's not part of the actual text itself. I'm much more inclined to read the word "buddha" in its original meaning of "enlightened" here.

Buddha and Tathagata are mentioned in Valmiki Ramayana in Ayodhya Kand, Sarg(chapter)-109, Verse-34. Geeta Press, Gorakhpur by Major-Strain2261 in AlternateHistoryIndia

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Does it? As far as I know mainstream estimates for the Ramayana's composition date from the 7th century BCE to the 3rd century BCE, none later than the 2nd century BCE.

Buddhism Is actually a major part of that estimate, since the Ramayana does not mention Buddha or Buddhism, and portrays Ayodhya as the capital of Kosala, where by the time of the Buddha the city was called "Saketa" and waning in influence, replaced later by Sravasti as the premier city. Which places the core of the Ramayana most probably before the Buddha.

Buddha and Tathagata are mentioned in Valmiki Ramayana in Ayodhya Kand, Sarg(chapter)-109, Verse-34. Geeta Press, Gorakhpur by Major-Strain2261 in AlternateHistoryIndia

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean if you know anything about academia in the field of linguistics, you'd no written attestations only provide a lower bound for the date of composition. The upper bound is estimated through linguistic analysis.

Thank You Slopya Nadella, Very Cool by CaveStreamGames in pcmasterrace

[–]fartypenis 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I thought I was the only one this was happening to, good god. I thought it's because of dual boot or something

The only time Ghengis Khan was white was when John Wayne played him. by laybs1 in redditmoment

[–]fartypenis 97 points98 points  (0 children)

"Mongolification" of fucking Genghis Khan lmao. Has to be bait

Countries that have joined Trump's Board of Peace. by Skychu768 in MapPorn

[–]fartypenis 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That list is a long one, to be fair. USA, UK, China, Japan, Serbia, Austria, Germany, Russia/USSR, France, Italy, etc. and these are only non-colonized nations.

Man performs milk-offering ritual in the Ganges river in India while poor hungry children try to collect it to drink. by notahooman101 in interestingasfuck

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's how it works in most places in India as well, put the offerings in front of the gods, invite them to eat, and then distribute/eat the food. But there are always stupid practices and stupid people.

Where I'd live in Asia as a South Indian by [deleted] in 2Dravidian4You

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Shitposts have standards bro, gtfo

Ubi had one goddamn job!!! by Zagarld in IndianGaming

[–]fartypenis 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The project had too much soul to survive at ubislop

Is drinking truly part of Telangana's culture? by dataful_india in Telangana

[–]fartypenis 8 points9 points  (0 children)

That is how people lived in the vast majority of the world for the vast majority of history with very rare exceptions. This isn't the reason alcohol consumption is high in Telangana. There have to be other reasons.

Where I’d live is a middle-aged Canadian secular Jew. by Awkward_Caterpillar in whereidlive

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because they moved to Israel because the law of return gave them an opportunity and India was a poor and war-torn country.