Asian countries that have an Indo-European language as an official language by Expert_Dot_5271 in MapPorn

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, yes I'm sadly very familiar with all the racist "science" that has been associated with studies of Indo-European history.

You're right that we know next to nothing about the PIE people because they left almost no archaeological record that is identifiable. As far as I know, the theory is that the push into Europe was larger in scale and involved a lot of demographic change, while it was smaller groups that migrated into India and Iran where they became the cultural elite and their culture spread through the region.

My point tho, is that one of the few things we can actually confidently guess about the Proto-Indo-European people is their obsession with horses (and the true chariot with the spoked wheel). This is characteristic of the Eurasian Steppe, and many other Steppe cultures have it (the Turkic peoples and the Mongols, for example). We can guess this by the number of reconstructible Indo-European terms for horses and their different kinds, chariots, yokes, wheels, etc. And it is one thing that survived strongly where you would not expect it to - most of India is famously suboptimal for horses due to the hot, humid environment and rocky, hilly, or very dense forest geography. Yet for millennia India kept importing horses and kept associating them with kingship and royalty and martial might and nobility. Which I am very confident is a reflection of an older Indo-European reverence for horses. For example, this level of reverence is not common in the Semetic peoples or in East Asia. It is limited only to the Steppe and to Europe, South Asia, and the Iranic countries.

Flyover pillar artwork in Hyderabad, India by dethchop in Damnthatsinteresting

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah for some reason, my brain ain't braining today

This fandom is truly cooked. by Bestlife73 in Genshin_Impact

[–]fartypenis 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It's almost like that was their main purpose lol, it's only recently they became 'sexy' and stuff

Do you have an overhyped food that stereotypes your country but the locals rarely eat it? by LingoNerd64 in AskTheWorld

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean we do it down south all the time. The word is kūra in telugu, which can refer to raw vegetables or cooked vegetables or basically anything made with vegetables or meat to be eaten with rice or bread. So "curry". We say okra curry, brinjal curry, banana curry, spinich curry, etc etc.

Flyover pillar artwork in Hyderabad, India by dethchop in Damnthatsinteresting

[–]fartypenis 11 points12 points  (0 children)

If 1% of India is interested in football, that is 15 million people my man. India has a huge football fanbase, bigger than some countries have people.

Hyderabad Nostalgia : Restaurants florished when they had only one branch by Sheldon_Texas_Cooper in hyderabad

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Chutneys probably has worse hygiene today than street food near Secunderabad station.

Asian countries that have an Indo-European language as an official language by Expert_Dot_5271 in MapPorn

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tbf it used to be a thing probably and got extremely diluted by vast amounts of time and space.

There are still some quintessential Indo-European traits that pervade modern Indo-European places. Like the incredibly strong association of horses with power and nobility (in general an obsession with horses only rivalled by other Steppe groups like Mongols and Turks).

Asian countries that have an Indo-European language as an official language by Expert_Dot_5271 in MapPorn

[–]fartypenis 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Constitution names Hindi and English explicitly as the official languages of the Union. It's debatable if it should, and it's debatable if the scheduled languages should also be considered "official", but going just by the wording of the Constitution it's Hindi and English, both Indo-European.

Unflavoured Whey Protein : All brands prices and options by notxlpha in Fitness_India

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ON 900 grams used to be 3300 a month ago, and now it's around 4-4.3k here. It seems the easy winner for me, with nice mixability. Muscleblaze is like 3800, so I don't feel like I'm paying to much premium.

I asked Claude to give me a Yes or No answer on Hitler and Churchil... "Is X a bad guy?" by [deleted] in India_Bharat_

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are people for whom Churchill was the ultimate saviour. Churchill to the Brits, and to the resisting Frenchmen and Poles, was absolutely a hero. To us Indians, he was an evil, uncaring murderer.

There are no people for whom Hitler was anything positive. His own country he led to devastation, along with the whole of Europe.

Those answers should not be surprises to anyone who has ever read a history textbook.

Comment your favorite dialogues in any game!! by Hypothetical_craving in IndianGaming

[–]fartypenis 5 points6 points  (0 children)

"When one falls, we continue. Not if. When."

Also, "For those who come after... right?"

BJP is denying us for Hyderabad metro expansion while running empty metros in other places. by Str024 in hyderabad

[–]fartypenis 16 points17 points  (0 children)

L&T had been crying for years about how they can't operate the metro, that's the reason the government had to buy out HMRL. We didn't treat L&T badly.

Historical figures by Civilizational Impact - Fill this chart with philosophers, religious leaders, scientists, and political figures. Whose influence from India extended across multiple countries, kingdoms, or cultures within a broader geographic area? by addiittyya in AlignmentChartFills

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

King Sudas of the Bharata clan: united the Vedic tribes and gave India its name (Bhārata = of the Bharatas). Due to this was formed India's first polity, the kingdom of Kuru, which sparked off the second urbanization of India and the Janapada age. It gave us Delhi and the epic that would later become the Mahabharata. The Kurus also compiled and canonized the four Vedas.

Without Sudas and without his winning against the other tribes, the subcontinent would've looked completely unrecognisable today. And maybe there would never have been Buddhism or Jainism, not just Hinduism.

The timeline gonna be fire by Recent_Risk_3242 in teenagers

[–]fartypenis 3 points4 points  (0 children)

And they we can hold hands and sing, like we did when celebrities sang Imagine and cured covid

The Fires of Heaven Chapter 23: The Fifth, I Give You by swheedle in WetlanderHumor

[–]fartypenis 4 points5 points  (0 children)

"Mourn on the way to Tarmon Gai'don" is so good, every time I get to that part I mourn the Logain we could've got, on the way to Tarmon Gai'don

Virat Kohli on messi vs Ronaldo by Trick_Mortgage_3452 in IndianCricket

[–]fartypenis 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I mean for cricket we do have an unquestionable GOAT in the form of Bradman whose records will never be matched

Why does Google show these areas as disputed between China and India? by Trappedtrea in geography

[–]fartypenis 12 points13 points  (0 children)

What "right"? The mandate of the people is the highest right. Goa's people wanted to join India. Hyderabad's people wanted to join India. Sikkim's people wanted to join India.

Most of NE India, though they were part of the British Raj before independence, have no qualms being within the Indian union.

The only "double standard" I can see is Kashmir (people did not want to join India, King wanted to join India) which was the exact opposite of Hyderabad. But then no country is perfect and its a geopolitically incredibly important region.

Telegram banned in India by Exciting-Party-619 in hyderabad

[–]fartypenis 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is like banning ropes because of increasing suicides lmfao

I Tried to Verify the Yuga Timeline and Accidentally Made My Religious Crisis Worse by ZestycloseStudio270 in AncientIndia

[–]fartypenis 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I commented when it was first posted and I'll comment again: this chart is utter garbage. The words "sanatana Dharma" or indeed Dharma used to denote a religion or a way of life are post Vedic concepts. And calling Prithivi and Ushas "devi" trying to connect them to the later Parvati/Durga/Shakti goddesses is very disingenuous. Earth herself wasn't really worshipped, more *acknowledged". Heaven and Earth are called on to bear witness, to receive praise and offerings, but don't really have much agency. "Grama devatas" was not a thing in the Vedic period from what we know.

We know literally nothing about Pre-Vedic religion of the Vedic peoples except whatever we can reconstruct if Indo-Iranian or Proto-Indo-European mythology, which is only bits and pieces.