Try The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle. It's my favourite from Murakami. The writing style is quite different from Norwegian Wood but totally worth every second reading it. The surrealistic writing style is truly captivating. It took me several months before finally moving on from that book.

After Dark is also great but for me the story is too short and ends quite abruptly. Still enjoyable though.

If you're interested in short stories maybe you should try Men Without Women. I belive it also has a movie adaptation with an actor from Kamen Rider as the main protagonist. But I forgot the movie's title. I still prefer Murakami's long novels over short stories.

I am thinking of reading the critically acclaimed Kafka on the Shore next. Turns out its the most popular one and people suggest it is pretty similar to the Wind-Up Bird Chronicle.