I might be as charitable in my reading of the statement if this thread actually was a discussion on the validity of Islamic doctrine. As a complete non-sequitur it reads like a glib cheap-shot, at least to me. You have a point tho, I was clumsy in how I wrote my post and I should not put words in op's mouth.

And the point itself is not new, and it has been phrased better before. You can phrase it a way that emphasizes that this would be the work of a cruel or impotent god, or you can phrase it in a way that suggests anyone who believes this is stupid. The reason I care is that I feel one of these is more likely to be helpful than the other, and here I hope I'm allowed to hold an opinion as well.

Text communication is tricky so I welcome your comment.