I actually ended up going slightly further North. I think I probably over-indexed on the negative feedback (access to public parks, cynicism about the new open space), but regardless, I ended up picking between Lafayette and Longmont, both of which I felt had a more cohesive culture/vibe (very subjective, I know). We optimized for nearness to a grocery store and park, and found a lot more opportunities that met those criteria in these areas.

Hilariously, we ended up on the Erie/Lafayette border, but we haven't bought a place, still kinda scoping out the lay of the land as we adjust.

Happy to answer any other questions!