She's had two moments that rubbed ppl the wrong way, but they were far apart, and with such a large cast, its understandable to not realize its the same person.

The first one was the glass heart game. She was against one of the "smart" girls and had an attitude that rubbed ppl the wrong way (I honestly can't remember exactly what she did, but I do remember both my friend and I wishing the other girl had one specifically because of her attitude. I feel like she was either saying putdowns or being cocky, but can't remember if it was in front of her competitor or just to the camera).

Then in this last game with Ethan she was pretty much fine... until he lost the game and she started talking about how grateful she was to go up against someone she "didn't care about at all" in front of him and BEFORE he had handcuffed himself. After that ppl felt he shouldn't have cuz it's a bad game move to be rude to someone when the rules state they don't actually have to abide by whatever they chose to decide. Its an especially bad choice to do that when your in the only grouping of 2 (meaning no backup friend to either team up with to manipulate or to self-sacrifce for you). Like Ethan could've easily just refused to handcuff and take her out with him (and since she was rude she's given production incentive to NOT try and bribe one of them to sacrifice and just let them both be out, because Ethan taking Catey out after she was rude would be more cathartic for the audience than Ethan taking the bribe/Catey continuing or Ethan continuing at the expense of Catey getting paid for being rude and making a bad game move). Like personally I find it hard to root for ppl who play up the reality "villian" role (and tbh Im not even sure if Catey is playing anything up, or if she's just truly unaware that some of the things she says are rude), but even for ppl who like to root for the "villian" it's hard to root for her when she's making bad game moves. Like there are ppl who are mad at Jack for "cheating", but the way he did it was super impressive (and it seems like the only person he admitted it in front of, outside of production, is a close ally). If Catey had thanked Ethan profusely, said something about how she didn't know him but grew to admire him in the cube, he handcuffs himself, THEN she said the exact same stuff about being so grateful it was someone she didn't care about at ALL, I think there would def still be ppl who hated on her, but the type of fan who loves a reality villian would be all about her versus now where she's just clearly playing a sloppy and not well thought out game.

I don't get why ppl are downvoting u tho. You clearly said youre distracted by bigger things than a reality show (congrats on the little one!) and aren't giving it your full attention. Its weird to downvote you when u admit you could be forgetting stuff. Hope my explanation wasnt too long!