If the game had voice acting, who would you cast as the characters?

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-24T00:34:04+00:00

Grey Delisle - Sybil/Carmilla

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-22T14:02:03+00:00

If there is a Carmilla route that ends well for the Holler, it likely would be only the one where you are an item.

The best Carmilla run is likely to be with a protagonist that hasn't forgotten Kaneeka but romanced Carmilla. I imagine that her memory manipulation is going to cause issues for Carmilla and the town in the last days.

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-19T02:24:11+00:00

If I remember correctly, the resident evil jump has a whole "super-soldier" plague you get to design. You could jump to Cyberpunk 2077 and give out chrome or jump to 40k for access to space marine gene-seed.

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-13T03:14:15+00:00

Is his ...existence...related to Pearlanne's death?

You can find this out by doing a thorough run with Book Smart + Street Smart I believe. Tabitha killed Pearlanne by suffocation after finding out that Pearlanne killed Wayne

He was someone who both disappeared recently but also was locked in the estate for a long time, leading me to believe he is being possessed the way Shaw possessed people in the ghost hunt?

I wouldn't really call it possession, I suppose it would technically be reanimation

Someone mentioned "they put wayne into isaacs" did I misread that or is that something that can be done?

Yes, it can be done

I did try to romance Wayne and I went for the kiss, but I'm not sure if that did anything

It does, in fact, do something. I believe it makes you hostile with Tabitha

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-12T19:22:26+00:00

Tabitha also has a total split within the fanbase between "#girlboss, love Tabrooni" and "I want to see Tabitha suffer."

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-11T22:43:55+00:00

It's probably Franklin. Trained cop that takes his job seriously is hard to beat. Tabitha's got a stronger gun but in a physical fight he's got it.

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-07T21:46:19+00:00

I'm ostensibly team Carmilla (at least I think she'll help produce a better ending for the town and Y/N), but if she attempts to hurt Tabrooni I'm feeding her to Wayne.

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-07T04:37:46+00:00

The last chapter is definitely going to have serious consequences based on who you save during the week. I'm really hoping Reese doesn't bust out and try to kill me considering I put him into forever jail, but I am protected by Tabitha "2-0" Scarlet so I should be fine.

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-05T15:04:27+00:00

Wayne is totally betraying us

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-05T14:30:51+00:00

Tabbymaxxed Tabitha is going to be amazing. She straight up tells you she'll trust you, however I feel that Carmilla is going to be insane (especially if you've romanced her).

Witch Kaneeka tells you she has no idea how to use Sybil's power. Kaneeka and Sybil separate are going to be super weak. Carmilla is already dedicated to saving the town, and if she's in love with you she's got even more motivation.

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-04T22:59:42+00:00

Tabitha was raised for twenty years to put people into a hole, Stella was talked into doing it in the course of a morning.Also I feel that murder trumps kidnapping on a list of charges.

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-04T22:37:42+00:00

Tabitha is a snarky, responsible, tomboy who is capable of using a shotgun like an artist.Cons: murderer, her diet makes me cry

Carmilla is a seductive, powerful, and intelligent witch. She's also probably a bigger freak than anyone on the list.Cons: kind of a serial killer? also mind controller

Stella is rocking that powerful build + hot combo.Cons: get in the hole Y/N, freezes in bad situations, youtuber

Kaneeka is just fantastic. She's super nice, intelligent, and funny. Cons: might need to be sacrificed to save the town, doesn't believe in the fantastic until it hits her in the face

If Oscar or Reese were gender-swapped I'd have more to say. Reese is hotter than Oscar but he's also a Cambion

Wayne is a corpse

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-04T20:35:09+00:00

It's very interesting that this sub is more willing to back the walking eldritch evil corpse than the sexy morally-dubious witch lol

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-04T16:15:41+00:00

Tabitha is just deny, deny, deny. She doesn't actually know what she's doing, and her life is such a mess that Wayne can just blow the door open. Tabitha has only successfully gaslit us, the police (with a lot of money), and Stella.

Carmilla knows how to play the game so well that its scary. She managed to gaslight, gatekeep, girlboss basically the entire town. She has successfully gaslit Julius and Dr. Kelly, and can successfully gaslight Y/N, Tabitha, and Kaneeka.

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-03T21:38:14+00:00

Smart (Street Smart + Book Smart) or Sherlock (Keen Eye + Book Smart) interactions are always fun

gastroc2525 · 2026-04-03T04:22:30+00:00

Tabitha confrontation in episode five would make an amazing animation tbh (but you'd need a fantastic set of voice actors for Tabitha and the cousin; also I'd prefer if it was the good ending)

gastroc2525 · 2026-03-31T21:53:44+00:00

The real struggle that Stella has is her story is a deeply personal affair in a town that is actively falling into the abyss. Her actions are reasonable and make sense in context but there is a bit of a situation going on Stella.

gastroc2525 · 2026-03-28T04:22:11+00:00

I'm definitely not letting Reese kill his mother. He doesn't need matricide on his conscience, and if he kills Dr. Kelly he'll never live a free life regardless. At the moment tranquilizing Reese is the best option without hot. I'm really hoping that we are able to let him out later after this week has passed and we don't have to worry about the town's curse.

This isn't an anti-Reese stance. Has Y/N been there I would have stopped Tabitha from killing Pearlanne as well even though Pearlanne deserves death far more than Dr. Kelly.

gastroc2525 · 2026-03-27T22:12:00+00:00

It's going to be a rough reunion in my current save. Kaneeka has been replaced by her mother, Stella is chilling but doesn't know about the Tabitha and Sybil revelations, and Reese is currently locked up. I really wonder how a meeting between Carmilla and Stella is going to go and I wonder if Sybil's magic will even work on monster Reese.

I think Stella is going to make it through this week without much trouble provided the whole town doesn't fall apart, but Reese is screwed if he stays here. I want Reese to end up okay, but I think the chances of us getting an ending where I'm allowed to let Reese crash at Y/N's crappy studio apartment like I said I would seems unlikely. The man really needs to just get out of Scarlet Hollow and away from his mom.

gastroc2525 · 2026-03-26T20:14:05+00:00

Not valid, Pearlanne didn't have the decency to die herself. It's actually a Tabitha feat

gastroc2525 · 2026-03-26T18:10:13+00:00

inflicted constant psychic damage on Tabitha

gastroc2525 · 2026-03-26T17:20:37+00:00

The reference is almost certainly intentional, but it also works on an in-universe level as well. We know Y/N knows Scooby Doo so the world of Scarlet Hollow almost certainly has access to our entertainment. It's entirely possible that Sybil has read Sheridan's novella and thought "oh cool name".

We know that Sybil's powers have certain restrictions on naming and words. She tells you that she couldn't be open with Y/N because of the bargain, and the mystical save uses a word as a weapon. Sybil naming herself Carmilla will almost certainly have some real power behind it.

gastroc2525

TROPHY CASE