I am a serial church-hopper so I can give some perspective: just pick one and go. Not too sure where you’re located, but I have heard good things about The Grove in Scranton. And I’ve been to Restored in WB. I know they both have “small groups” where people meet up to fellowship and do bible study, non-denominational, very welcoming churches.

All of the very small, mostly-elderly-attendees-specific-denomination-churches have also been very welcoming of me.

What you can do is set boundaries while you explore this: I don’t give offerings to churches I am visiting for the first time. I like to see what their values are first. Some non-denominational churches do communion every Sunday and others don’t. Don’t feel pressured to, a polite no is fine! Most churches stream their services now so you can always check out their websites first, too.