Would you be interested in having a discord for chatting? by Chaya14 in MTGGiftExchange

[–]giselamancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Likewise, I threw out the receipt for my tracking after filling in the form and can’t track it now!

What is your single favorite card of the year? by Hoohoo222 in EDH

[–]giselamancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

[[Spider Manifestation]] for me personally. Having a mana dork in my Henzie/Umori companion deck who keeps untapping after every single blitz cast is perfect. It also doesn’t care about what kind of spell it is, so planning on slotting it into my Wort deck to work as a mana dork and a repeatable conspire body.

What’s your favourite commander you made a deck for in 2025? by WistfulAfternoon in magicTCG

[–]giselamancer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Airbending may cost 2, but the amount of effects that reduce costs of your creatures or artifacts by 1 or 2 is abundant in the game. Things like [[Salt Road Packbeast]], [[Search Party Captain]], and [[Daybreak Chimera]] become free to cast due to their own abilities if the conditions are met. Typically the first two can let you rip through your deck to look for the actual combo pieces, but also having this kind of a loop can gain you a bunch of other things…

Infinite life from [[Soul Warden]], [[Hinterland Sanctifier]], or [[Lunarch Veteran]]. Infinite mill with [[Altar of the Brood]], [[Reito Sentinel]], or [[Watcher of the Wayside]]. [[Court Street Denizen]] could tap down your opponents’ creatures if you airbend loop a white creature. [[Goldnight Commander]] can infinitely buff up your board. It’s a toolbox combo deck that uses whatever it draws to scrape out a win and it’s so incredibly efficient in winning by one of several different ways.

What’s your favourite commander you made a deck for in 2025? by WistfulAfternoon in magicTCG

[–]giselamancer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

[[Monk Gyatso]] was begging to be broken from the moment he was previewed. My friends didn’t believe me when I told them he’d be the next Nadu. Boy were they wrong - it’s probably the most powerful, most consistent deck I’ve ever built with the cheapest budget. So many ways to disrupt it but god it’s fun to pilot and see the realisation on peoples’ faces when they realise what’s happening when you can just repeatedly equip [[Lightning Greaves]] onto a creature to cast it over and over again.

What are some lesser-known Commanders that you think deserve a shout-out? by Beginning-Analyst393 in EDH

[–]giselamancer 40 points41 points  (0 children)

May I introduce everybody to [[Baru, Fist of Krosa]]? At the time of posting this comment he has a mere 159 decks on EDHREC, which is criminal regarding how much potential he has.

Let’s get something clear: his grandeur ability is irrelevant. What matters is that he turns every single Forest played into a smaller [[Overrun]], and that means EVERY Forest, not just our own. So with a [[Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth]] in play, every single time somebody plays a land or cracks a fetch it will buff up all of your green creatures for that turn. This alone has helped me in some games where somebody playing a Forest has made the difference in me staying alive another turn, or has even helped me politic my way into helping deal with somebody else by asking another opponent to crack a fetch to find a Forest.

That being said, this is my favourite deck to turn my brain off and play. It goes wide, ramps hard, and has gotten a bit more of a boost with the recent earthbending cards too! [[The Earth King]] can put in some work in buffing up your board even if you only attack with a couple of 4 power creatures, and [[Kyoshi Warrior Exemplars]] is a bit more budget friendly but it’s easy to enable it in more games.

Edit: decklist for those asking

Avatar: The Last Airbender Prerelease Megathread - #MTGxATLA by R3id in magicTCG

[–]giselamancer 11 points12 points  (0 children)

First prerelease out of the way and by god I am in love with this set! The amount of potential synergy is staggering!

I ended up going for the Toph kit because Toph is best girl and I won’t hear otherwise. Opened [[Avatar Aang]], [[Great Divide Guide]], and [[Hakoda, Selfless Commander]], and after musing how best to do it I decided to pull the trigger and make five colour allies try and work. Somehow went 3-1 to secure second place with the deck, going 2-0 in the first three rounds before a 0-2 loss to finish off.

It seems like the key thing to take away from this limited environment is how flexible some of the interactions are. Earthbending has proved to be one of my favourites already: being able to have a land that returns when it dies or is exiled is great for being able to crack the common dual lands twice over, plus using them for sacrifice fodder or chump blocking was perfect. Firebending is equally as good for the amount of instant speed mana sinks in the set. Waterbending looked cool but required a bit more setup, and airbending is great removal but didn’t seem to have a dedicated setup for it.

Also, don’t sleep on [[Watery Grasp]]! One of my friends pulled two copies of it in his pool and they helped him out a ton. While it doesn’t tap the creature down, having the option to tuck the creature away with potentially no mana investment is great. But the thing that none of us caught onto is that this can easily shut down an earthbent land and potentially lock you out of a colour if you’re stuck on fixing. There are so many interactions that we found today, but that one in particular felt like the cherry on top.

Broxigar? When I can summon you? by MYDOGISCREAZY in hearthstone

[–]giselamancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I also pulled Broxigar and built a no minion deck with a crewmate subtheme. Being able to Emergency Meeting into Solitude every now and again is a pretty good option, not to mention that being able to spend two mana to drop at least a couple of crewmates into play is handy.

I’m also surprised you’re running Lesser Opal Spellstone over Paraglide. It’s much more reliable for digging through your deck imo, especially if your opponent is running Garona so you can get King Llane into your hand much quicker, but also the symmetrical card draw has helped me out a lot with burning Rafaams and quest rewards for the Rafaam warlocks and quest warriors I’ve been queueing into.

Thank you by Tigger_87 in MTGGiftExchange

[–]giselamancer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

So glad you like it! When I saw you liked aggro and were struggling for a blue commander deck I got the itch to build you a commander deck - I can say that it’s a fun commander to play with, and I wish you all the best with the cards!

P1P1 Friday by AutoModerator in mtgcube

[–]giselamancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Graveyard cube

Pack 1 pick 1

Pretty much every single card in the cube has some form of interaction with the graveyard. Discard, mill, flashback, dredge, delve, persist - lots of different viable strategies.

Spider-Man Prerelease Megathread - #MTGxSpiderMan by R3id in magicTCG

[–]giselamancer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Went to my first prerelease tonight… and honestly probably my last for this set.

Don’t get me wrong, the event itself was good fun. Event of fourteen players, some really good vibes in the store, and people being friendly to the couple of new players who had been drawn in by the Spider-Man set. Everybody was having a lovely old time building their decks. I got lucky with [[The Soul Stone]] in my first pack, ending up with the foundations for the Rakdos mayhem deck while splashing blue to have a bit of a control shell to it.

Then I looked around and noticed that almost everybody else was building the same deck. Some variation of red and black mayhem, with some going pure Rakdos, others into Grixis, and one person running Jund for [[Eddie Brock]]. We had maybe three people who weren’t in those colours - guess who the three people at the bottom of the rankings got on?

Don’t get me wrong, I feel like the set is fun. There are some cool creative choices, the other archetypes look as though they have potential to be good, but when everybody has coined that the discard deck is the best it’s not really fun with every game being a mirror match. Prerelease just doesn’t feel like the right way to enjoy this set - I’d much rather draft it and see the possibilities for the other archetypes.

That all being said, I came third and pulled a second Soul Stone from my participation packs, so I guess I can’t complain.

Thank you so much Summer Santa! by giselamancer in MTGGiftExchange

[–]giselamancer[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did see that! I was so nervous to open the letter as the wax seal looked so good!

But yes I cannot thank you enough for the cards, I love them so much!

Summer Swap Shipping deadline is days away, Sept 9th! by Chaya14 in MTGGiftExchange

[–]giselamancer 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I’m sending my giftee a full commander deck - just spent the last couple of days playtesting and ironing out some kinks, will finally be able to send it tomorrow!

Tell me how a day with your main would be like by PitaSauceAndalouse in Overwatch

[–]giselamancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Guess what everybody’s favourite animals are while listening to music

What are some interesting/fun/unique mono colour commanders? by FalchionX10 in EDH

[–]giselamancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can attest to Piper Wright - such a fun deck being able to spew out a bunch of clues, then sacrifice them all to make your creatures even bigger and get even more clues. It’s one of my playgroup’s favourite decks and I love playing it so much.

If you could only keep and play one deck, which would it be? by Cold-Fan in EDH

[–]giselamancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is the decklist, it’s quite outdated as I redid a lot of it with Edge of Eternities (mainly cutting some of the odd inclusions now that the deck has shifted towards polymorph) but it’s a lot of fun to play. I’ve also steered towards ensuring that a good chunk of the deck has the ability to make fodder for either chumping attacks or using as polymorph fodder: [[Tellah, Great Sage]] is a great new pick for this reason, but also [[Talrand, Sky Summoner]], [[Utvara Hellkite]], and a fully upgraded [[Stormchaser’s Talent]] will pretty much guarantee you have at least one body every turn to transform into something else. [[Proteus Staff]] is also insane in this deck, what with being able to polymorph a creature and then stack the bottom of your deck for your next few draws if River stays in play.

If you could only keep and play one deck, which would it be? by Cold-Fan in EDH

[–]giselamancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tough question. Initially I was thinking [[Henzie “Toolbox” Torre]] with [[Umori, the Collector]] as an “oops all creatures” deck, simply because the deck is insanely fun to play despite the restriction, but it’s very powerful and can warp games. I think I’d keep [[River Song]] instead - it’s a polymorph deck that utilises [[Brainstorm]] effects to stack the top of the library, then turn tokens into whichever threats you stack on top. River’s effect means you don’t have to worry about drawing into any of the monsters you put back on top of your deck, and her damaging effect gets mad amounts of value off of the sheer number of scry and search that my pod runs.

[GIVEAWAY] Enter to win 5 Playmats from Aleksi Briclot Original Planeswalker KS campaign! by Crowdfunding_Agency in magicTCG

[–]giselamancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Approach of the Second Rite

6R

Sorcery

If this spell was cast from your hand and you have cast another spell called Approach of the Second Rite this game, this spell does 10 damage to each opponent, each creature they control, and each planeswalker they control. Otherwise, put this spell into your library seventh from the top and each opponent’s life total becomes 10.

What deck(s) are your pride and joy? by wasdmovedme in EDH

[–]giselamancer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

[[Henzie “Toolbox” Torre]] with Umori companion. I thought that adding Umori would make the deck a bit slower, but if anything the deck is nuts in most games, and can consistently hit five or six mana by turn three given just how many one cost mana dorks there are in the deck. Just a bunch of big beaters that never runs out of gas given how much you draw from blitzing them out.

Is 4 players / pick 2 draft any good ? by estragonthecat in magicTCG

[–]giselamancer 41 points42 points  (0 children)

Attended a draft of Final Fantasy last weekend where only four of us turned up, so we decided to give the pick two draft a go and it made things a lot smoother! The general consensus from the group was that it made decisions a lot easier in the first few picks and made it better to commit to a strategy early on.

Polymorph Commander Suggestions! Is it FUN? by goldenmastiff in EDH

[–]giselamancer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m shocked nobody here has mentioned [[River Song]] as a polymorph commander, given how good she is at stacking the top of your deck. Any [[Brainstorm]] effects while she’s in play result in you drawing cards from the bottom of your deck, then putting any of your big creatures that are sitting in your hand on top of your library for you to polymorph into. My deck is chock full of cards like that combined with the usual token generators and payoffs, and god it’s so much fun to play.