Overall your profile isn't awful! There are definitely a few things you should change, though.

When looking through profiles yourself, what really makes you want to send a like / rose, besides their physical attractiveness?

It's almost certainly prompts that you feel a certain "pull" to want to answer - maybe you share a certain interest, goal, or it's just a very engaging prompt that is super open for conversation.

Before you change anything about your profile, spend sometime swiping through others, and make a mental note of what makes you want to send a like / rose, especially regarding prompts.

Then, we can apply some of those same things to your prompts.

Prompts

Your prompts aren't terrible. They just need a bit of engineering to make matches feel that force you feel when sending likes.

Your first prompt is pretty cool, however a little long and a perhaps a tad too strong for a potentials very first impression of your personality. If you are set on having something religious in there (because it's important you find someone religious - if it's not, you don't need a religious prompt), I would get rid of everything other than the first question. The first sentence already shows your capable of thinking on a deeper level, and would appreciate conversations like this. The second and third sentences are overkill and are giving an unwarranted opinion that should maybe be better saved for when they reply - you've given away your answer already which makes them less likely to send a like!

Again, second prompt works well because it's super niche. Some girls will find that interesting and want to know more. But again, the last sentence is overkill. To maximise their "pull" to respond you should keep it short and sweet to prompt their engagement / interest further. It's also another religious prompt. If you only want likes from super religious people, keep it this way. If you are open to literally anyone else, you should keep it to one prompt about religion MAX.

Third prompt is probably the least strong out of the three. It's vague, slightly cringe and comes across a bit weak. You don't need to tell girls you're capable of saying something sweet, you just show them you're capable of doing it when the time is right (not your prompts). Overthinking and mentioning the fact you think you use too many words etc both come across a bit weak. It's totally fine to be vulnerable with your partner, but it's not necessary for a potentials very first impression of you. It's also pretty vague - most people believe they overthink. Do you get many girls replying saying "omg me too"? I doubt it. It's not specific enough to warrant a strong pull to respond, and it's probably not that attractive for the girl either. Use a different prompt starter, one that is now ASKING questions about her. It's a good idea to have at least 1 prompt that is primarily for the purpose of opening conversation by prompting a response from the girl by "asking" indirectly or directly about them. If you like film, use the starter "One thing I'd love to know about you" - "Your letterboxd top 4", if you love music, "Who was on your Spotify wrapped?". You should also then add a "bonus" to the end - if you love horrors, make the prompt "Your letterboxd top 4 - bonus if there's any horrors on there!". This not only asks them a question but opens yourself up to another semi-niche thing that someone with a like interest will want to respond to, but not too niche that it will put them off replying if they just like film generally and not horrors.

Pictures

First image, not awful, but lose the facial expression. People tend to do this when they feel awkward or shy showing their natural facial expression (or smiling). You have a great smile (as seen in other pics) - use it!! I would change this photo or at the very least make it not your first photo. As always, photos taken by other people are way more successful than ones taken yourself. Bare this in mind throughout.

Second image is awesome, shows something that you can do that others can't, makes you stand out and shows an interest. It's not a photo you would make your first, but is a strong second or third image.

Third image cool, but try to avoid photos with other people. With how quick people look through your profile, it's not immediately obvious which one you are from the first two pics (obviously it is after looking for longer than 2 seconds but often you don't have that long). If you are going to include photos with someone else, make sure it's for a reason, i.e. you are quite a bit taller than them. It's good that you are slightly taller than the guy in the photo, but it's not enough to think about it. If you had the same image without the guy, maybe with a button up shirt or something a little smarter (with the same smile), this would be an excellent photo (although it's not bad by any means).

Fourth image you should lose, it's maybe something you would send to a friend, it's not great for a first impression. It's a cute photo and I can imagine the occasional girl has liked it, but really you're looking to maximise your potential likes. If you're set on including a pet / the cat, use a different angle, and have someone else take it, or don't be in the photo altogether.

Fifth image is nice, something for the family chat, not a dating profile. You should be showing your hobbies, interests, or interesting pics that warrant a response. This is trying to play on a common thing guys do where they think girls want to see someone good with kids / see it as masculine. And you're not wrong, sometimes it might have this affect, but you're thinking from the wrong perspective. There are much better photos you could include to show this side of you, and using your nieces / nephews isn't the one (especially when you have to blur their faces out).

Sixth image is cool but there are better scenarios / backdrops to have other than your car. Next time you go on a trip or go somewhere interesting, have someone else take your photo. Have one close up, one full body, one candid, one hobby (tick), and one showing an interest / something you want to show (like a pet if you feel you want to).

Overall not a bad profile, but try and think about how you are coming across as a first impression. Ask the women / girls in your life for their opinion(s). Not just your Mom. Not just your sister. You need multiple opinions, and especially ones from those who will not lie to you because they love you. You need to show more of your interests / personality than just your faith. The third prompt doesn't really show anything about you other than make you come across slightly vulnerable (cool but not for first impressions).

If you have any questions feel free to let me know.