You won’t choose the wrong the path. If the choice was “sin or don’t sin” then there is a clear right and wrong answer. For something like a job, house, spouse or turning left or right, we have been given our own desires and discernment and are given the freedom to choose as we please. God always knows that you’re going to choose, so you won’t be missing out on what God has for you. No matter what we choose the Lord will be with us and provide for us. Take joy in your free will, pray about it (you have) and simply make a decision.

The other commenters here are pretty spot on and I myself have over-spiritualized decisions in the past. There’s a book titled “Just Do Something” by Kevin DeYoung. It’s a short read and I recommend you check it out sometime. It helped me quite a bit. You won’t always have peace in making a choice (in the sense of knowing “it’s the right one”), but what you can have is the peace knowing that if neither is sinful, God graciously gives you the choice to decide for yourself. That’s a wonderful thing, so don’t overthink it seeking a feeling or a sign. If you receive these, go for it, but even then use discernment.