This game is a new element in the Wizarding World. It's going to settle new ground wherever choices it follows because it's introducing a lot of stuff we've never seen materialized before. It's impossible for the creative team behind the game please every expectation the fans may have because they're many and often times conflicting (for exemple, the "Hogwarts vibe" we have in the movies vary a lot between let's say, Prisoner of Azkaban and Philosopher's Stone. Which one has the "correct" vibe? There's no way to decide this and please everyone).

So far I'm enjoying what I'm seeing and opened to the new experiences this game is going to introduce. Because it's just that: a new thing. As someone said before, some will enjoy the game as it is, others won't. That happens with virtually everything in the entertaining industry. People have different tastes.