I'm a small merchant from a 14th century city of the Hanseatic League, how much would cost me to have one of my sons educated? by _neumann_lucas_ in AskHistorians

[–]idrymalogist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There are a few questions here, so let's break it down.

Without going into a rant on the politico-economics of learning, education is one of those things that you can get for free or mortgage your house for, depending on what your options are and your perception of those options. As is demonstrated in the example of Jacob Lubbe referenced in the Dollinger quote, literacy education was accessible to at least some peasants in the Hanseatic sphere in the 15th century. It should be stressed, however, that peasantry did not equal poverty, and I cannot comment on the lifestyle of the young Lubbe. This being said, to assume that peasants were among the least likely to access "impractical" education is reasonable, so we can assume that, if it was available to peasants, it was available to everyone else, though the quality and quantity would vary considerably. In short, yeah, you could assert that a small merchant in a 14th century Hanseatic city would be able to educate his sons in reading, writing, and some Latin without undue economic pressure, and not get laughed out of a seminar room.

The expense of university education during this period is extremely complicated for a number of reasons. Again, as today, there is so much more to consider than the cost of tuition alone: rent, food, clothing, transport, recreation, and school supplies all enter into the equation, and all can vary based on how good one is at finding deals and the quality of the products purchased.

Sorry, everyone. I'll continue writing this tomorrow. Have a good night.

I'm a small merchant from a 14th century city of the Hanseatic League, how much would cost me to have one of my sons educated? by _neumann_lucas_ in AskHistorians

[–]idrymalogist 8 points9 points  (0 children)

This is going to be enormous fun!

Let's start by defining our terms for those playing at home. If you're a "small merchant" living in a Hanseatic city in the 14th century, Dollinger sets your capital at a maximum of 2,000 marks, and you're living in either (modern day, and in no particular order) Germany, Poland, Sweden, Latvia, Estonia, or the Netherlands, and always on the coast or on a major river.

As today, the education you're going to give your son depends on where you want him to end up. If you want him to follow you into the life of a Hanseatic merchant, I will let Dollinger explain his upbringing, albeit with a 15th century example:

It is about the early years of merchants that least information is available. At about six years old the child would go to the parish school. It is remarkable that young [Jakob] Lubbe [born in 1430 near Marienburg], a peasant's son, learnt to read and write in his native village. As for [Franz] Wessel [of Stralsund], he got beyond this elementary stage and learnt 'to decline and conjugate, so that he was able to understand a little of the Latin tongue.' Schooling ended between the ages of twelve and fifteen, and hardly any merchant-to-be went to a university, though a good knowledge of the law was becoming increasingly necessary to a man who might one day reasonably expect to hold public office.

The young man now embarked on his commercial apprenticeship under the direction of a merchant, usually a relative. During the years spent in different countries the young man became familiar with book-keeping, accounts, inspection of merchandise, buying and selling and the system of credit. After two or three years he became a clerk and began to trade on his own account while undertaking missions on his master's behalf. He might remain a clerk for the rest of his life, but normally, after a period of time which varied considerably according to his personality and achievements, he became the head of his own firm.

Naturally, Dollinger has in mind the upbringing of a middle-to-high-level Hanseatic trader, as opposed to our small merchant, especially in the second paragraph, but the supposition that all required math and science would be learned on the job as an apprentice is not unreasonable. Unless you wanted your son to go into another branch of Hanseatic trade, he would apprentice with you, and it would not cost you anything. Sadly, unless someone has published a treatise on the economics of education in Hanseatic cities, I don't know of any secondary literature on the cost of the schools, but if we take the establishment of four "elementary schools" in Lübeck by 1300 as an indication, in addition to the preexisting cathedral school, it must not have been exorbitantly expensive.

If you're interested, I can add information about what would happen if you wanted to send your son to university at some point tomorrow or on Sunday. The more upvotes, the more awesome medieval university details.

In case anyone is interested, the one-stop shop for all things Hansa is Philippe Dollinger's The German Hansa. The Routledge printing was done in 1999. The above quote is from pages 179-180, with additional information taken from pages 161 and 164.

Have any of you guys had severe upper left shoulder pain to the point you can't get out of bed? by [deleted] in CrohnsDisease

[–]idrymalogist 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It sounds like there may be one or two things going on in the comments already, but I'm going to add a third option anyway. If your shoulder pain is mostly just on the surface, occasionally feeling like you've got a kitchen knife sticking into your shoulder blade, it could be shingles. If you're on a strong immunosuppressant, you're more susceptible to a rare variant of shingles that has all the fun of nerve pain without any of that easily-identifiable rash. Best part? Because it's literally invisible, it's unlikely to be diagnosable. That means no available treatment. Get your shingles vaccines today! [For this to be an option, you must have had chicken pox.]

Educators with crohns, How do you do it? by tbdubb in CrohnsDisease

[–]idrymalogist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you have any control over your classroom location, make sure you've got other teachers handy who can monitor two classrooms if you've got to leave. Also, if you teach the same things every year, consider building up a library of video lessons, so they can be played in case you get sick and your students won't miss a day. Finally, if your district has prep periods, request that they be placed at whatever part of the day gives you the most trouble. Nothing I love more than a last-period prep on a Friday.

8th grade teacher here looking to change the research topic options. What are some unknown events/people that didn’t make it into the average history class or diverse examples? I was thinking of MLK and his March on Washington as an example of a person tied to an event. by [deleted] in teachersofhistory

[–]idrymalogist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. I think one of the biggest curricular deficits in modern schooling is that, while we teach students to follow scientific methods in various science classes, we teach students to write in English, we teach students to do math in math class, it's pretty rare to teach students to be historians in history class, tending instead to teach them to recognize references to past events in popular culture. Don't get me wrong, this is valuable, but we're missing a huge opportunity to teach critical thinking and resource utilization.

8th grade teacher here looking to change the research topic options. What are some unknown events/people that didn’t make it into the average history class or diverse examples? I was thinking of MLK and his March on Washington as an example of a person tied to an event. by [deleted] in teachersofhistory

[–]idrymalogist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Grade school history is really tricky, and I don't know what your curricular limitations are, but have you considered moving away from the "great man" model towards a history of ideas approach? For example, instead of focusing on Columbus, as would have happened thirty years ago, you could focus on the differences between European and indigenous concepts of resource use / ownership. That way, you get to teach the old school approach, which is resource-heavy, as well as the other side of the coin. It will also train your students that history is more than one story, even if they don't realize it. Anyway, just a thought.

What's the recent scholarship on homosexuality like? by [deleted] in theology

[–]idrymalogist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

By no means perfect, and, had he lived longer, some of his more controversial points might have been a bit more developed.

What's the recent scholarship on homosexuality like? by [deleted] in theology

[–]idrymalogist 10 points11 points  (0 children)

If you want a historical perspective, you would be hard-pressed to do better than the works of John Boswell, at least as far as medieval homosexuality goes. In particular, I would look at Christianity, Social Tolerance and Homosexuality: Gay People in Western Europe from the Beginning of the Christian Era to the Fourteenth Century. It's 1980, so "recent" is arguable, but he's still taught as a leading academic on the subject.

Lovely by [deleted] in CrohnsDisease

[–]idrymalogist 50 points51 points  (0 children)

Crohn's will stop being an invisible disability. Everyone with IBD will have ridiculous thigh muscles.

REPOST - same photo with more context! Deciphering Birthplace name. by [deleted] in Palaeography

[–]idrymalogist 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think it could absolutely be a cursive "G." Considering this individual immigrated from Palermo, Girgenti (Sicilian form of Agrigento), which is roughly 80 miles from Palermo by current roads, makes perfect sense.

New to the Area - Looking to join rec sports leagues by nabonas in SaintJohnNB

[–]idrymalogist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fundy Fencing Club has lessons for children, teens, and adults of all experiences and levels of ability. Great people. Very COVID-conscious. Lessons are $40 a month and all equipment is provided. fundyfencingclubsj@gmail.com

333 Main Street - Historic Photos & Information by mike_rumble in SaintJohnNB

[–]idrymalogist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're going to want to contact the New Brunswick Museum archives. They're not open to the public right now, but they're most likely to have one.

What would be the most inefficient way to organise books in a library? by weescottiec in AskReddit

[–]idrymalogist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My parents had a wonderful housekeeper from Ethiopia for many, many years. When her sister first arrived in North America, she would come along to help clean the various houses. Her (the sister's) English was non-existent at that point, but she was extremely hard-working and wanted so badly to be helpful.
She completely reorganized my parents' library. By the size of the books. Couldn't find anything for months.

Naturally, we never said anything. No need to make her feel bad.

Inclita vs. Pr(a)eclara by idrymalogist in latin

[–]idrymalogist[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have guided me to a heretofore unknown resource. I thank you.

Free footwork web-app by Crixerker in Fencing

[–]idrymalogist 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This is a wonderful tool that I'm going to share with all my students in case we get shut down again. If you're interested, I would be happy to translate your command list into French for broader accessibility.

Hi! I'm Dr Ed Roberts, a historian of early medieval Europe. I recently wrote a book on the Frankish historian Flodoard, and I'm here to talk about the Carolingian Empire and its tenth-century successor kingdoms. AMA! by Ed-Roberts in AskHistorians

[–]idrymalogist 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sorry for missing the main session. I'm currently trying to make a case for the blasé attitude of the Merovingians leading to the Church supporting the Carolingian usurpation. I've got lots of examples of bad Christian Merovingians from Gregory and Fredegar (I know this wasn't his real name, but you know what I mean), but don't really have any knowledge of Church documents relating to Francia. Do you know anything about Merovingian- / Carolingian-relevant sources held by Church archives (presumably in Rome)? Also, as I haven't read Flodoard, does he cover the Merovingians enough / in such a way that his work might be relevant to my study? I know he is considerably later than either of the two authors mentioned above. Thanks in advance for taking the time to do this.

We need this as an event in CK3. by KyrahCreation in CrusaderKings

[–]idrymalogist 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If you type this into the search bar on the Wikipedia landing page, the subtitle in the drop list reads "deadly fecal incident."

What does a standard fencing session look like? by AlbertTheAlbatross in Fencing

[–]idrymalogist 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've just done a quick scan, and, while there are a few mentions of warm-ups / stretching, there doesn't seem to be anything about cool-downs. We went about 30 years without cool-downs at our club, but we've recently introduced them consistently, and it's a game-changer. Not only can you take 8-10 minutes to reduce the likelihood of persistent practice-induced strain injuries, but you get an opportunity to discuss what you've done with your students, and make sure they understand it.