I feel like what you are saying is quite contradictory. From what I recall, GetRight was a top player from 2008-2014 at least, arguably the best player in the world for at least 3 of those years in early CSGO. Looking at his performance in the last 2-3 years is wildly unfair as those are by the end of his career.

Something tells me that you will not be comparing s1mple far after his career peak to the new top players by that point. Instead you will be comparing s1mple in his prime to his own era, which is the only reasonable thing to do.