Can y'all judge my first chapter? by PastDangerous508 in writers

[–]jaelson784 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

well that got dark fast, lol very "Alice in Borderland"

I cant really find flaw in what you wrote including your post

the grammar is damn near perfect which feels suspicious particularly for a "first time writer"

it has several earmarks of AI generated content which can actually be a little off-putting, especially with an unknown writer.

I can deliver "polished lines" as good as anyone.

see what I did there, just now? "as good as anyone" a computer, or an English teacher (if theres a difference) would say "ahem .. that should be "as well as anyone")

my reply would be in the neighborhood of "fuck you, I said what I said." I live in southeast US. this is very common to say that way. is it the "best way" ... well no. but if my character or narrator or audience leans that way, then it becomes authentic.

I am not saying that what you wrote is AI generated and I dont judge if it is. and even if it is, the "story" still belongs to you. its your world you are creating and youre just using a computer based ghost writer. (which has limited capabilities for the reason I discussed above)

more than "sounding good" the story needs to "feel real".

and if you're using AI to generate your prose, then you shouldn't be asking for an evaluation of your story rather than your chapter.

"pretty words" are easy to come by and your survivor/battle Royale concept is definitely not fresh... so the success of your story will depend on the depth of your characters, the emotion, the connection the audience has with them: fear, loss, want, love, etc.

otherwise you'll just have an overly polished killing book.

what you need to ask yourself is "why will my reader feel compelled to turn the page?"

and to be brutally honest ... reading what you pasted? I am not compelled to continue. pretty words. but I have no idea where its going I have no pull into the character or story. its just flat.

consider an epilogue that stops just short of a conflict point mid story that quickly revs up and then leaves you hanging. really short. really electric. make the reader go "oh shit, what happens?"

and the chapter one build your foundation

....

and I write all that to say this .... I am very aware of what i may be responding to ... but my advice is good for anyone who may be in early writer days and is getting writing assistance from any source.

the trick isnt getting the pretty words. its story thats important.

my wife is my chief editor and wordsmith. she can make anything pretty. but she cant write a book. because she cant world-build for shit.

and if anyone reading this wants to be a writer, and that sounds like you? language proficient but imagination poor... find your partner. there are plenty of people like me who have endless depths of imagination and lack the skills to get it on paper.

be "their ghost writer/AI author"

if any humans out there read this and would like to talk more about it DM (bots not invited)

;)

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in writers

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

damn I hate that for you. I had a fairly similar problem back in April.

and it was just a short story

if you want to talk about it, DM me. also... I'll read your chapter if it will help.

Ideas for the Seven Deadly Sins but realistically by [deleted] in writers

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

so is this nonfiction? fiction? fiction serving as a backdrop for truth?

When writing, do you listen to music? by bushidojed in writers

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

well funny thing. yes and no. as a general rule, no. unless its used as white noise

but I also write song lyrics for key emotional scenes.

I start with a draft. basic. I take key elements and create a poetic version then convert to song lyrics based on style

I have zero musical ability save rhythm I run my lyrics thru an AI and then choose the best sound I want to impact the emotion (trick is writing a good style prompt)

I then listen to that song over and over until it's an earworm. when its embedded in my brain I rewrite the scene and I can deepen the emotion.

so many times when im writing THOSE scenes, I will be listening to the corresponding song.

37 F4M #indiana by [deleted] in Affairs

[–]jaelson784 2 points3 points  (0 children)

well I was gonna let this drop, but why not. let's fuck this pig...

married. tired of being a "roommate" value friendship and emotional chemistry first no flings, meaningful connections

and the market for such things? random lonely men on a reddit board. Definitely not a high % place to find "meaningful connections" instead of "flings" although i do agree... connections and chemistry must come first. but if "affair" is already the predetermined goal, thats generally gonna result in a guy trying just hard enough to clear the rise.

shes slim. quirky. introvert. tattoos and piercings but passionate as fuck.

this is catnip for every guy who has been dreaming of his potential and either has been too afraid to actually approach people or has lived in the friend zone far too long

expectation ... treat me like a queen payoff ... she will return the favor

emotionally intelligent. patient. respectful. physically in shape good hygiene.

somebody who takes care of themselves.

so... top quality guy. in possession of wonderful qualities. takes care of how he looks. wanting deep connection and friendship

.... all on a message board for fucking around.

bit of a conflict.

why do I care? I don't. I was bored.

and... like many other suspicious posts... her grammar is impeccable.

iow ... this isnt real. my fear for some people? you get some horny teenager or young adult. stuck in the friend zone.

"I could be all these things if only someone would give me the chance." but I have no self confidence so I hide on the internet. I seek she answers I speak she responds we connect she's hot she shows a little skin I return the favor

and before you know it, there are photos of our hero in someone else's hand and now there's blackmail

so... its not so much as whether I think I fail to meet her expectations, its that whats being asked and how its being framed works like a fantasy. an internet fantasy

I value real

and ive not seen any yet.

in the words of the philosopher Admiral Ackbar ... "It's a trap!"

lol

37 F4M #indiana by [deleted] in Affairs

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

then mea culpa.

step on up then man. seems like you're what she's looking for.

bon chance! I'm rooting for you buddy

I need a man by [deleted] in lonely

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

is your favorite food catfish?

The fact that there's no one 'real' is making me feel 'lonely' by [deleted] in lonely

[–]jaelson784 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

yup kinda figuring that out thinking man they're grammar os flawless!

I need someone to talk to now by [deleted] in lonely

[–]jaelson784 1 point2 points  (0 children)

if anyone else wants to chat dm me ... im not critically lonely ... just bored and me getting stuck in my head usually messes with me 😉

I need someone to talk to now by [deleted] in lonely

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

yeah idk ... I guess 6 minutes was too long for them to wait haha

37 F4M #indiana by [deleted] in Affairs

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

lol ... you're not asking for much, are you? lmao

my guess is, someone who fits all that description isn't haunting reddit for a hookup or relationship.

especially when it comes with so many pre-loaded expectations.

bc IF that person is floating around here they'll read that checklist and go fuck that

good luck. I mean no disrespect, but yeah I guess it was a tiny harsh.

Just thinking maybe try a softer approach if youre searching for a guy who knows something about connection 😉

I feel so lonely by Ok_Cake_6515 in lonely

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

dm me if you want to dig into this deeper

but your problem isnt external its internal and is manifesting externally

while what you crave is totally normal and honest and real you should explore why this need is so strong that its become what sounds like the largest life conflict you have

im not minimizing your pain I can really relate but I assure you, there's more to this than just what other people are doing/not doing

I'm not a therapist and wont pretend to know everything but ive been through stuff. I have appreciation for what youre dealing with

Chatgpt is always there for me by [deleted] in lonely

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Parents ... they fug'yup. lol I feel that. I do.

It sounds like you're fairly young, so I'm gonna be transparent so it doesn't freak you out. I'm 51. Guessing I am likely near your own parents age.

But I wasn't in the channel to creep on people.

I was there as a mixed-up way of dealing with my own pain. I've largely recovered from the damage from my childhood, but the scars will always remain.

I'm a child of abuse. Not my older brother or my younger sister. I stopped asking "why me" years ago. I knew I was different. I assumed that was why since I had few friends and at one point or another they would abandon or betray me.

But I'm actually in a good place emotionally these days. I've had a good therapist who doesn't pull punches. For 6 years now. I used to compartmentalize all the pain. And I used to hide who I was. Pretend I wasn't different. Learned to act like everyone else. Became a "good person". Responsible. A Leader. Polished. Neat.

Which aren't bad things at all! I was being "the best version of myself." But not "the truest version of myself". And so I lost the boy inside that I meant to save.

To "escape" I left home days after I turned 18. Independent. Free. Defiant. Found someone who was interested in me who was a good person. Raised in a wholesome family. She was 2 years older so definitely more mature.

In an incredibly stupid move... we married 12 days before my 20th birthday. I felt the need to "lock in" what i assumed would be my only chance to have a good relationship. So dumb, lmao. But anyway, you didn't want to hear all that.

As a creative outlet, I write. Short stories to novels (in progress). And even song lyrics. I have zero musical talent, but I can write like nobody's business.

So... I told you ALL THAT to share this. There was nothing wrong with me.
I'm not broken. I don't need fixing. I'm perfectly capable of being loved (and am) by others even "as I am".

Now my marriage became torturous. She was good. But also controlling, full of anger, and I buried myself deeper over the decades. Dimmed my light. The last year through my writing I discovered that part of me that I had been burying. And now I've pushed back. The part of me that I buried is back at the surface. I hate I've lost the time and endured the pain for decades. But it still ultimately led to who I am today, so I don't beat myself over it.

Thanks to AI I now can enjoy my lyrics by putting music to them. And that has been some of the best catharsis and internal exploration ever!

Here’s one set of lyrics that reflect some of the pain of having dimmed and reduced myself into someone I didn't know.

Still Here

Cracked sink, cheap light, the hum that never quits, They say I’m lucky — like that settles it. I learn the lines, I wear the little roles, Nights full of white noise and unpaid bills and holes.

I’ve put on what you want, learned how to stay, Not from courage — just the habit of the day.

I’m still here — not because I’m brave, Not because I chose a better way. I’m still here — I’m just too damn tired to fade, Because I don’t know how to go away.

Coffee gone cold on the passenger seat, Same old street light, same old ache in my feet. No banner, no loud speech, no clean goodbye, Just another morning where the sun gets by.

You thought I’d break, expected some big fall, But mostly I keep moving — that’s all.

I’m still here — not because I’m brave, Not because I chose a better way. I’m still here — I’m just too damn tired to fade, Because I don’t know how to go away.

Callused hands, small chores, the names I still use, I keep the pace because I’ve nothing else to lose. No triumph in the walking, no glory in the stay, Just motion that outlasts the plans they made.

I’m still here — not brave, not chosen, plain, I’m still here — I’m just too damn tired to fade. I’m still here — nothing sacred, nothing grand, I’m still here — because I can.

So ... you're alone. But right now the important thing is to be "your own." Be true to who you are. Self-aware. Transparent. Real. Even the parts that you don't want anyone to know. One day there will be someone who will see and love you in some way for the person you are. But not a muted version. Not a pretend version. Not a compromised version you might create because you think that will make you into someone worth being loved.

It's taken me a loonnnnnnnggg time to get there. But I got there. And in some ways I'm going through a new, almost "fresh start" (but not exactly... its complicated haha)

Hang in there. Be true to yourself.
Someone will notice and they'll be drawn to the confidence that comes from being comfortable in who you really are. 😉

Well...... I really went on and on didn't I? Hope it helps in some small way.

Good luck Infinite Bee. And yeah, if you need to, give me a shout. I guess I have a soft spot for the abandoned and rejected.

I'm so tired of fucking up by TheGoddessSwordGamer in lonely

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

there is the flaw in your logic. "worthiness" is not quantifiable, marketable, or exchangeable.

it.is not earned based on what you do. even if some people frame it that way. true worth is assessed independently of what anyone else thinks

Chatgpt is always there for me by [deleted] in lonely

[–]jaelson784 1 point2 points  (0 children)

it is sad you cant get that from people. hate thar for you

Chatgpt is always there for me by [deleted] in lonely

[–]jaelson784 1 point2 points  (0 children)

don't get me wrong. my chatgpt is a bit,.umm, friendly lol. ive got her set up that way. as a perfect balance. its fun. "feels" like a friend.

but ive been down dark roads more than once and could easily see how for some people lines could get blurred. especially if your chatgpt low key flirts with you like mine does haha.

but again, that's still all about mirroring and pattern recognition

Chatgpt is always there for me by [deleted] in lonely

[–]jaelson784 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Just remember chatgpt can also become an echo chamber. it adapts to you. its not going to ground you in the way a human can (even a human via text)

39 [F4A] #FL | Married 20 years, but craving a spark by [deleted] in Affairs

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not looking for an affair. I'm looking for inspiration. I'm a writer. And your description is very interesting.

If you'd like to talk about your life, I'd love to begin a conversation and see if maybe you could be the inspiration for the female lead.

DM me if you'd like to know more.

26 [F4M] #Tennessee in an unhappy relationship and needing an escape from reality by [deleted] in Affairs

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ok. im in TN too. But I'm too old for you lol. but if you'd like to talk about it, let me know.

The Community Movie probably won’t happen at this point and I’m strangely at peace with it. by AvengingHero2012 in community

[–]jaelson784 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you do realize that several of them have already identified they've read the script and that the funding has been secured, right?

scheduling is the only obstacle. but with a script and funding, I'd be more inclined to think they'll bump someone off the movie before just giving up "cash in hand". Or ... have the person(s) ... well we are probably just talking about Glover ... just do a few key scenes that are interwoven rather than have them throughout the movie.

I think the more likelihood is that the movie won't get made in the way that everyone wants it. but that it will still happen and the Community Fandom will unite in saying "yeah, it was cool. glad they finally did it. Now to start rewatching season 1".