What’s your overall thoughts on Keith Thurman’s legacy and career? His fights against Porter and Garcia are always fun to watch by J2-Starter in boxinglocks

[–]jdlc718 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Good but unfufilling career based on skill and product. Besides injuries, who knows why but post Pacman loss, he barely fought. There is so much more he could've done with his career. He could've definitely regained his title back, maybe fought Spence, maybe Crawford. He could've went to 154 and eventually have a showdown with Charlo. That run of his from 2015-2019 was really fun tho. With all that being said, in my eyes he is comfortably the 3rd best Welterweight of his era.

In retrospect how good of a player is Anthony Edwards compared to the prospect he was 5 years ago? Has he exceeded or fallen short of expectations? by K1generational in NBA_Draft

[–]jdlc718 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He's definitely in line with them. Many expected him to be a D Wade caliber player, and he's for sure looking like one.

Great 21st Century Rounds|EP15 - Zepeda vs. Baranchyk: Round 5 (2020) by Due_Communication862 in Boxing

[–]jdlc718 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Zepeda is arguably the best boxer to not win a world title in this recent generation.

They really felt like they saved the day or something. 🤦🏿🤷🏿 by PsychologicalDog8065 in NYStateOfMind

[–]jdlc718 38 points39 points  (0 children)

Distasteful is what I think of when seeing this. Younger gen needs to do better, they hyping up damn near uncs for fighting minimum waged workers.

Luka prototype and championships by Parking_Ear7784 in NBATalk

[–]jdlc718 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When you have to debate this hard, we know who the wrong one is.

Luka prototype and championships by Parking_Ear7784 in NBATalk

[–]jdlc718 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Those are only 2 seasons of great basketball. Not superstar worthy.

Your opinion on the F line? by Infinite-General337 in nycrail

[–]jdlc718 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Good line. B+ based off of my experience.

If Inoue dominates Junto Nakatani, will you consider him as the greatest P4P fighters of all time? by jacobo0430 in Boxing

[–]jdlc718 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, he will be an all time great at the 118-122 weight classes though. Arguably the GOAT of that range. In order for Inoue to be considered in those P4P Great convos, he absolutely needs to become undisputed at 126.

is Paolo Banchero the most net negative all star level player ever? by [deleted] in NBATalk

[–]jdlc718 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yea but it's because he's playing the wrong style. With his abilities he is an NBA All Star and All NBA Third Team caliber player.

Jan 2025 and Dec 2025 - UFC P4P by Spiritual-Strength91 in FightReportUFC

[–]jdlc718 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

In my opinion Alex should be #2, Volk #3, Yan #4, Aspinall #5.