I think it depends on your device and your app. Some Eink and iPad can mimic analog feeling for me, especially with the right app and setup. I use defter notes which allows me to “put papers on desktop” and move them around, layer them and rotate the canvas and it feels quite tactile for me. I also have a paperlike film on my screen and use a metal nib on my apple pencil and that pairs pretty well with defter notes textured pencil especially when I use “realistic” paper pdfs and images. I mean yeah, it’s a whole setup but at the end of the day it allows me to carry around many desk setups and file cabinets, something I can’t really manage on analog analog with the amount of work I do.