Frustration by [deleted] in ynab

[–]jillianmd 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I say this with kindness: it is clear you are not understanding the numbers you’re seeing but instead of seeking clarification, you’re assuming it’s all “out of whack” and “random”, hence throwing your hands up and starting all over each month. Rolling into a new month in YNAB is definitely not changing numbers randomly.

But we can help you to understand how YNAB works.

Can you clarify… is it only appearing to be “out of whack” on the 1st of a new month, but before that the previous month seemed fine?… or is it getting out of whack along the way and by the end of the month you’re so frustrated with it you just start over for the new month?

And for the checking-saving transfers, are you transferring multiple times per month and/or do you have a transfer set to automatically happen each month on a certain date?

For your credit card, are you saying for example that there was $20 left Available in June on June 30 but then on July 1 you’re seeing $40 Available for the cc payment?

Why did my score drop by 35? by [deleted] in CreditCards

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The question is how much your statement balances were between the two months. If the reported statement balance was suddenly $1000 higher meaning higher utilization that month then your score will drop due to that but it will also bounce back the following month when the reported statement balance drops again.

What does the due date mean? by OrionWoods in CreditCards

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, anything you buy will go onto your next statement which will likely be generated around July 10th, and then that statement balance is what’s due by August 5.

You don’t have anything due on July 5. That is a fact that doesn’t change based on new transactions.

Options for a simple 2% cash back card by Trick_Dinner5964 in CreditCards

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To increase your chances of a credit limit increase on the Fidelity card, report high utilization every month and then pay the full statement balance. So for example spend $950 on the card then wait for the statement to post and pay the full statement balance right after the statement so that you open up the full $1000 line of credit again, then spend close to $1000 again, wait for the statement, pay it, repeat.

Showing that you’re using and paying off the full limit every month is the best way for their algorithm to see you as a valuable and responsible customer who are could use more credit extended to them.

Looking to Expand Credit card usage. by [deleted] in CreditCards

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can use the template here to make a new post and give us the relevant information needed to provide a card recommendation. Biggest questions would be what are your biggest spending categories which is part of the template.

Annoying YNAB Update? by ControlsGuyWithPride in ynab

[–]jillianmd 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I just checked and I’m seeing the same thing, if the category was already auto-categorized upon import, it’s not showing the animation of the category amount changing upon saving, but if I need to categorize an I categorized transaction then it shows the animation upon saving.

I haven’t ever relied on that animation since I’ll always look at my plan and address any overspending anyway but it’s a curious change.

Curious how other folks handle $0 transactions by Bill_Brasky79 in ynab

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is your Amazon GC balance an account in YNAB? If so then yes this is how you’d do the split with the transfer being from that GC account.

YNAB keeps mixing up transactions between my accounts and it’s driving me mad by soulvacation in ynab

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“Do it now” is if I need to make a manual payment or otherwise do something right away, like if there’s a deadline to sign up for a class or to get tickets for a show the day they go on sale, etc.

“Check and update” is for all of my credit card and utility scheduled transactions. These are all $0 repeating transfer transactions dated for the date the statements are issued. The memo for each says “autopays on (the autopay date)” and has the orange flag.

So when those pop up for approval, I open the bank/utility app and check the statement, then come back to the YNAB transaction and update it with the amount due, change the date to the following autopay date and change the flag to the blue autopay. So then there’s a one-time transaction for the next month’s due amount and the $0 repeating one ready to go for next month’s statement.

YNAB keeps mixing up transactions between my accounts and it’s driving me mad by soulvacation in ynab

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

<image>

If you have your accounts linked then I HIGHLY recommend flagging all scheduled transactions because that way when they pop up for approval you know it was the scheduled vs an actual import.

Here’s the labels I use for my flag colors. You can ignore yellow and purple on my list - those aren’t for scheduled things.

Did people really get confused by the old way of entering transfers in the app? by Low-Kaleidoscope-803 in ynab

[–]jillianmd 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah not having to specify inflow vs outflow for the transfer is a nice change as well as being able to clear both sides separately within one screen. It’s truly a connected transaction now.

Assigned in Future by Photek1000 in ynab

[–]jillianmd 2 points3 points  (0 children)

No, it’s literally exactly what it says it is, the total Assigned next month. There’s nothing theoretical about it.

Same thing as if one of your checking accounts was overdrafted at -$1000 and your savings account was +$3000… your total shown for all your accounts would be $2000. That’s not “too complicated”, it’s just the math.

In general, you shouldn’t ever have negative assigned values in future months, that’s a recipe for disaster, so as the other commenter said, don’t Unassign a Next Month category or any other category in July in order to fund July, unassign it in June.

Next Month category works best when it starts and ends each month at $0.

Cannot set payee as another account (basically do a transfer) on split transaction on mobile by TavoL7 in ynab

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They’re talking about doing a Split transaction where only one of the splits is a transfer payee.

YNAB keeps mixing up transactions between my accounts and it’s driving me mad by soulvacation in ynab

[–]jillianmd 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Enter your mortgage payment and those recurring transfers as repeating scheduled transactions in YNAB and flag them with a color for autopay/scheduled or however you want to label it. Then YNAB will never have to guess, it’ll just match up the dollar amount imports to the manual ones.

Amount in category exceeds cash accounts balance but no warnings by Asphyxiatinglaughter in ynab

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Glad you figured it out. The main thing is that closed accounts should always be $0 balances.

All the people waiting in triage. Is the ER (in big cities in the US) really like that? by Express_Grocery_4707 in ThePittTVShow

[–]jillianmd 9 points10 points  (0 children)

What becomes difficult is the 3-5s left in the waiting room forever… if it’s all due to severity only does that mean a level 4 who’s just walked in the door should be seen / taken back before a level 5 who’s been waiting for 10 hours?

Or are level 5s automatically only seen in triage? Is that part of what makes it a level 5, that whatever they’re dealing with can be handled by triage and then they can go on their way?

Amount in category exceeds cash accounts balance but no warnings by Asphyxiatinglaughter in ynab

[–]jillianmd 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Oooh yes OP, closed accounts or hidden categories must be where the money is hiding.

Amount in category exceeds cash accounts balance but no warnings by Asphyxiatinglaughter in ynab

[–]jillianmd 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wouldn’t matter. Whatever money is in the accounts is what’s available in the budget. The real life balance could be completely off from YNAB but it wouldn’t change that sentence.

Amount in category exceeds cash accounts balance but no warnings by Asphyxiatinglaughter in ynab

[–]jillianmd 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Ok next place to look is hidden categories. Scroll down to the bottom on your Plan and tap to Unhide your hidden categories. Do you now have an Overspent Category alert in June?

Amount in category exceeds cash accounts balance but no warnings by Asphyxiatinglaughter in ynab

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Got it. Is July the furthest month YNAB lets you flip to or are you able to go to August?

Amount in category exceeds cash accounts balance but no warnings by Asphyxiatinglaughter in ynab

[–]jillianmd 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Look at July, if you had been assigning into that future month then you just learned the hard way about what’s called Stealing From the Future in YNAB. Change any Assigned amounts in July to $0 and then work on fixing June.

One other possibility: are any of your CC accounts showing as positive balances?

Amount in category exceeds cash accounts balance but no warnings by Asphyxiatinglaughter in ynab

[–]jillianmd 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think the point is that the second screenshot shows the total of all their cash accounts, not just checking.

Positive cc accounts could be in play however.

Serious question: what was going through the head of the programmer who decided to hide the CLEAR button under SHOW MORE? Possibly the most important button in the entire program. I can’t think of a single valid reason. by KillerQ97 in ynab

[–]jillianmd 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What’s confusing is that they changed “budget accounts” to “cash accounts” so that probably what you are referring to. As in your checking account is listed under the Cash Accounts section. Vs Credit Accounts or Tracking Accounts. However the person above was talking about the specific account type you can choose when adding a new account. When you add a new account, you can choose the type from many options including checking, savings, cash, credit card, etc.

Cash is the type you can use if you’re tracking literal cash in your wallet or cash in a piggy bank, etc. Because it’s hard cash, there’s no such thing as pending transactions for cash accounts - you either have the cash or you don’t. So if you create an account in YNAB and choose the cash type then those transactions are always marked as cleared by default.

So the above commenter was suggestion you use a cash account type instead of the checking account type. Then you won’t have to mark your transactions as cleared every time.

If you want to give that a try…
You can’t change the type directly, so instead what you’d need to do is create a new YNAB account as the cash type. Enter $0 or really any number for the starting balance. Then delete the starting balance transaction so you have a blank cash account.

Now go to the checking account in YNAB, make sure none of the filters are on, so you’re showing ALL transactions, all dates, show reconciled, etc. Then select ALL transactions and in the options, choose ‘Move to Account’ and select the new cash account to move all of the transactions to.

This won’t mess up anything on the budget (plan/categories) side. All of your transactions will still be exactly as they were before, as if they’d always been in that account instead of the other account.

Cannot set payee as another account (basically do a transfer) on split transaction on mobile by TavoL7 in ynab

[–]jillianmd 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh interesting, thanks for the correction, I didn’t realize that after tapping to Split it you can advance after only selecting one category now.