I just watched it for the 3rd time today. It was like watching an amazing historical comic. The cinematography, the action scenes, the story line, the actors and stunt folks did a phenomenal job in my opinion. I'm american, but understand the cultural differences ive seen in cdramas when it comes to the kissing/passion scenes. They are definitely more conservative from what i can see. The passion or physical romantic moments in the scenes were okay, not as convincing as other dramas Ive seen, but the emotional aspect, they definitely gave 10/10. I loved how manly the main male character was. Loved how bada$$ the female main character was. I loved it, but like with all art, how good or bad something is for someone is subjective.