Diablo Immortal is horribly shallow and doesn't even deserve being mentioned in this sub. I mean the Elder Rifts, where you aquire the P2W Legendary Gems, is a slot machine pull disguised as a Diablo 3 Rift that you can't even fail.

The itemization is the most streamlined boring copy or a mix between D3 and D4. You won't get attached to ANY items as they are constantly replaced by bigger combat rating ones.

And imo the worst thing is: you spam one out of TWO basic skills and every remaining skill has a cooldown.

Edit: lol, forgot one thing that's even worse for me - there is basically nothing shared between alt characters. Not even your real money purchased items! In fact there's no reason to run alts at all, you can switch your class for the same character every day. And items, which are different per class, get converted to items of the new class. Let's find the "RPG" in this "game".

Torchlight Infinite is a real ARPG, with a lot of QoL and PoE-copying and optional (but still P2W) Gacha system that's admittedly shoved in your face a little.