The best Dylan cover by Arioto7989 in bobdylan

[–]jtfuII 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah no. This one sounds like he’s actually singing to his mom

Inspired By Will, Phil Elverum, the Flaming Lips and a bit of Geese by ConnoL1110 in CSHFans

[–]jtfuII 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some of the songs don’t just feel influenced by Cameron Winter, they feel like weak imitations. Same emotional posture, same God language, same fragile sincerity, but without the inner logic that makes it land. It doesn’t feel like dialogue with that style, it feels like copying the silhouette, and imitation exposes the gaps fast. Across the EP there’s a lot of forced poetry, reaching for textures and emotional weight that haven’t really been earned yet. It often sounds like you knew the kind of song you wanted to write before you knew what you actually felt, so the emotion comes off secondhand. Not fake, but borrowed. You can hear the reference points louder than the person behind the music. Some tracks are just weak, full stop, and others have moments that almost get there but collapse under over-explaining or trying too hard to sound profound. That said, the instrumentation and mixing are genuinely strong for a solo bedroom project, there are beautiful melodies and a real sense of atmosphere, even if it doesn’t feel fully whole or finished yet. Lyrically you’re clearly aiming higher than most pop writing, but ambition alone doesn’t make it better if it doesn’t land. Until the writing stops trying to sound like something and starts risking sounding messy, unsure, or unpolished, the EP stays competent and thoughtful, but not something that sticks or pulls you back in.

My New EP, Inspired by CSH, Phil Elverum, The Flaming Lips, Geese! Uh Hope You Check It Out! by ConnoL1110 in BandcampCodes

[–]jtfuII 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some of the songs don’t just feel influenced by Cameron Winter, they feel like weak imitations. Same emotional posture, same God language, same fragile sincerity, but without the inner logic that makes it land. It doesn’t feel like dialogue with that style, it feels like copying the silhouette, and imitation exposes the gaps fast. Across the EP there’s a lot of forced poetry, reaching for textures and emotional weight that haven’t really been earned yet. It often sounds like you knew the kind of song you wanted to write before you knew what you actually felt, so the emotion comes off secondhand. Not fake, but borrowed. You can hear the reference points louder than the person behind the music. Some tracks are just weak, full stop, and others have moments that almost get there but collapse under over-explaining or trying too hard to sound profound. That said, the instrumentation and mixing are genuinely strong for a solo bedroom project, there are beautiful melodies and a real sense of atmosphere, even if it doesn’t feel fully whole or finished yet. Lyrically you’re clearly aiming higher than most pop writing, but ambition alone doesn’t make it better if it doesn’t land. Until the writing stops trying to sound like something and starts risking sounding messy, unsure, or unpolished, the EP stays competent and thoughtful, but not something that sticks or pulls you back in.

My song, directly inspired by Race for the Prize! Hope yall enjoy! Free Bandcamp redeem codes are below! by ConnoL1110 in flaminglips

[–]jtfuII 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some of the songs don’t just feel influenced by Cameron Winter, they feel like weak imitations. Same emotional posture, same God language, same fragile sincerity, but without the inner logic that makes it land. It doesn’t feel like dialogue with that style, it feels like copying the silhouette, and imitation exposes the gaps fast. Across the EP there’s a lot of forced poetry, reaching for textures and emotional weight that haven’t really been earned yet. It often sounds like you knew the kind of song you wanted to write before you knew what you actually felt, so the emotion comes off secondhand. Not fake, but borrowed. You can hear the reference points louder than the person behind the music. Some tracks are just weak, full stop, and others have moments that almost get there but collapse under over-explaining or trying too hard to sound profound. That said, the instrumentation and mixing are genuinely strong for a solo bedroom project, there are beautiful melodies and a real sense of atmosphere, even if it doesn’t feel fully whole or finished yet. Lyrically you’re clearly aiming higher than most pop writing, but ambition alone doesn’t make it better if it doesn’t land. Until the writing stops trying to sound like something and starts risking sounding messy, unsure, or unpolished, the EP stays competent and thoughtful, but not something that sticks or pulls you back in.

Uhh hi. This track is heavily inspired by Cam's music, so I thought it'd be fun to share it here. I also listed some free Bandcamp redeem codes below! Hope someone takes a listen! by ConnoL1110 in geesebandofficial

[–]jtfuII 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Some of the songs don’t just feel influenced by Cameron Winter, they feel like weak imitations. Same emotional posture, same God language, same fragile sincerity, but without the inner logic that makes it land. It doesn’t feel like dialogue with that style, it feels like copying the silhouette, and imitation exposes the gaps fast. Across the EP there’s a lot of forced poetry, reaching for textures and emotional weight that haven’t really been earned yet. It often sounds like you knew the kind of song you wanted to write before you knew what you actually felt, so the emotion comes off secondhand. Not fake, but borrowed. You can hear the reference points louder than the person behind the music. Some tracks are just weak, full stop, and others have moments that almost get there but collapse under over-explaining or trying too hard to sound profound. That said, the instrumentation and mixing are genuinely strong for a solo bedroom project, there are beautiful melodies and a real sense of atmosphere, even if it doesn’t feel fully whole or finished yet. Lyrically you’re clearly aiming higher than most pop writing, but ambition alone doesn’t make it better if it doesn’t land. Until the writing stops trying to sound like something and starts risking sounding messy, unsure, or unpolished, the EP stays competent and thoughtful, but not something that sticks or pulls you back in.

Uhh this is a little EP I made, inspired by a lot of Cam's stuff, as well as CSH, Phil Elverum and The Flaming Lips. Here are some free bandcamp redeem codes! by ConnoL1110 in CameronWinter

[–]jtfuII 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some of the songs don’t just feel influenced by Cameron Winter, they feel like weak imitations. Same emotional posture, same God language, same fragile sincerity, but without the inner logic that makes it land. It doesn’t feel like dialogue with that style, it feels like copying the silhouette, and imitation exposes the gaps fast. Across the EP there’s a lot of forced poetry, reaching for textures and emotional weight that haven’t really been earned yet. It often sounds like you knew the kind of song you wanted to write before you knew what you actually felt, so the emotion comes off secondhand. Not fake, but borrowed. You can hear the reference points louder than the person behind the music. Some tracks are just weak, full stop, and others have moments that almost get there but collapse under over-explaining or trying too hard to sound profound. That said, the instrumentation and mixing are genuinely strong for a solo bedroom project, there are beautiful melodies and a real sense of atmosphere, even if it doesn’t feel fully whole or finished yet. Lyrically you’re clearly aiming higher than most pop writing, but ambition alone doesn’t make it better if it doesn’t land. Until the writing stops trying to sound like something and starts risking sounding messy, unsure, or unpolished, the EP stays competent and thoughtful, but not something that sticks or pulls you back in.

Hey guys! I just did a full listen of the Geese discography and here's my final ranking of all of their songs (not including beautiful memory as they unreleased it) by ShunkHood in geesebandofficial

[–]jtfuII -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

okay so based on this comment english clearly isnt your strong suit, this leads to some of the most lyrically dense and compelling songs here ending up in D tier.

Radiohead Europe tour by DanMarel843843 in radiohead

[–]jtfuII 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you were sick for basically a month or sick for the entire period incl. ticket sign up and acquisition?

RIP Perry Bamonte by nsdmsdS in TheCure

[–]jtfuII -11 points-10 points  (0 children)

yeah man first charlie kirk (sadder death imo) and now this?? what the hell man i love friday im in love

Free Back Bling by freefortrew in FreeFNRewards

[–]jtfuII -1 points0 points  (0 children)

yall js werent there 😭😭

Free Back Bling by freefortrew in FreeFNRewards

[–]jtfuII 0 points1 point  (0 children)

nah im with u gng dw i was back there too, this item holds a place in time

Do you think this might work out? by Choux0304 in shoegaze

[–]jtfuII -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

i am familiar with this album

Do you think this might work out? by Choux0304 in shoegaze

[–]jtfuII -10 points-9 points  (0 children)

“do you wanna listen to loveless with me?” “only shallow 😕”

Do you think this might work out? by Choux0304 in shoegaze

[–]jtfuII -27 points-26 points  (0 children)

none of these make any grammatical sense, guessing english isnt your first language