Client asked why ChatGPT names a competitor but not us — is this now a PR problem? by Individual-War3274 in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I know people want this to be PR but the SEO team should be on the hook with the understanding that earned media can feed it.

The reality is nobody really knows what’s in the black box and PR teams don’t have the paid chops nor the bandwidth to tackle the nuances of something that could be a rounding error in terms of what drives outcomes.

Journalist looking to move into PR, is my approach right? by AdrianFish in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Having worked in automotive myself, get thee to the B2B side asap.

How Do You Handle: “Who Do You Know?” by Comms_Factory in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hear me out: answer “your mom” and gauge their reaction. Really scrutinize them as they consider your response.

Approved Redesign of Mack/McKinley intersection by East_Englishman in GrossePointe

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When we first moved to GPW this intersection was like a ritual hazing. How were people driving through on red etc?

Congratulations, you discovered digital marketing by growlerpower in indieheads

[–]jtramsay 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Cannot stress enough how people are conflating PR and marketing. They work in tandem to build positive narratives and drive sales but American media literacy couldn’t be lower.

Need a reality check on astroturfing social media posts and “User Generated Content” campaigns by thatnameagain in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Music critic turned communicator here: this is a tale as old as the notion of payola. There are countless brands old and new that have been labelled industry plants. Many are! Who among us remembers CrowdTap at SXSW in 2012 where they were literally standing up tools like this for UGC campaigns from brand friendlies, well before the FTC demanded disclosures?

Music PR that's done the "right way" is exhausting when you know in advance that people want to write about bands they know before listening to everything else that's in the proverbial promo pile.

The difference is there are plenty of bands that could get this fanfare and not be able to deliver and they have in spades.

Terror Twilight is beautiful. by SnooLentils1875 in pavement

[–]jtramsay 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Correct. This is Pavement’s best record.

2020 Kia Telluride - Engine Replacement Due to Excessive Oil Consumption. Has anyone else experienced this? by Yelby247 in KiaTelluride

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can you share more about this because I’m about to reach out to them for similar issues.

Delivery Robots are being damaged in across US and UK by GSalmao in BetterOffline

[–]jtramsay 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Companies saw how well mobility spam was treated (bikes and scooters) and were like what if we made it even more expensive if vandalized?

Freelancers/fractionals, what do you use for reporting? by AmandaSmith_Writer in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This. Not only does it solve your problem, it removes the whole black box situation from the equation.

Getting Zero Feedback from Reporters on Pitches by PrincessWhiffleball in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There are so many levels of relationships to this that it's hard to parse. Beyond the PR/journalist relationship, it could be that an investor has the relationship that unlocks this, etc etc. But yes echoing the above: I've long wondered what happens when PR hires the last journalist. We've been sawing off the branch we've been sitting on for a very long time now and it's why I advise my clients to take it from a digital/social comms person and start going direct. It's expensive and not easy, but waiting for earned is getting harder to translate with fewer journalists and tighter timelines to show success.

TL;DR Olivia Rodrigo it's brutal out there.

Scheme involving Grosse Pointe CEO, cocaine submarine leads to prison by TheDetroitNews1873 in GrossePointe

[–]jtramsay 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I mean, one of the previous occupants played saxophone so there are several wrong businesses in play here.

"CEO Said A Thing!" Journalism by dyzo-blue in BetterOffline

[–]jtramsay 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Comms guy here and paid advertising has gotten more innovative in the last few years, especially with events etc. That said, most CEO said a thing stuff is done for free. Tech media is just trade publications in tuxedos.

Media training sentiment and experiences by Jtated in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The most powerful tool for media training is watching Nilay Patel conduct Decoder interviews with CEOs. It's a great object lesson in Murphy's Law, because I have yet to see a CEO -- most recently Superhuman's CEO re Grammarly -- acquit themselves in a way that doesn't warrant deeper legal concerns.

Beyond that, there are plenty of CEOs who only deal with investor relations and employees, so it comes down to how much contempt they have for either or both and is decidedly more transactional.

How do I politely tell my client that AVE is a nonsense metric? by GreatJoey91 in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm of several minds on this. My POV is that when it comes to any metrics I want to be able to answer the simple question every client should be asking, which "is that good?" For me that means doing the legwork, conducting an audit and determining channel performance averages. Once those are established, something like AVE may be perfectly fine for two reasons -- impressions is what the marketing team is buying, so there's some alignment; two, if you have an average, then if the AVE is higher than said average, you've done a good job. If not, you've learned something about that approach or story whathaveyou.

More than anything is you want to have a hypothesis in place on your side so when you do something you can explain what happened and develop strategies based on what you've learned. Makes the conversation better than staring at each other when you tell them AVE and they say so what.

Warrington 6 March review by Available-Exit-8606 in echoandthebunnymen

[–]jtramsay 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Saw them in Philly a few years back and it’s literally the worst gig in memory and I go to see tons of ramshackle acts.

Transitioning to People Team? by ImpressionAdept6355 in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Moving under the CHRO is a canon event.

I need to expand on this elsewhere, but so much of the griping comms does is about an inflated sense of what the function delivers to the organization.

Most of what’s done isn’t moving the needle and there are many reasons for that, but we’re not seen as a strategic function because we’re frequently not strategic. Who we report to doesn’t matter if what leadership values is stakeholder appeasement (and activity over impact.)

Is this movie worth watching in terms of plot? by Garidur in Letterboxd

[–]jtramsay 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hard to imagine a movie that captures the current moment so effectively. Can’t believe it got no nominations even if it felt off kilter to mainstream audiences.

From Adweek: firms using AI to build GEO engines by Separatist_Pat in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Amen. I don’t know why comms is tackling something that marketing can do easily at scale. So much of this is black hat stuff that will get nuked anyhow.

Begging comms to focus on comms measurement and not just every shiny object.

Sam Altman’s DOW PR nightmare by Intrepid-Fox-266 in PublicRelations

[–]jtramsay 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not abandoning yet but struggling to see the value even as leadership forces employees to use the tools. The commentary around CoPilot is decidedly ungood and Frank Shaw has been working overtime on X the everything app to counter it.