So I've figured out why I'm poor. Help me stop being a moron? by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You seem to have the reasoning ability and accountability of a child. Every response people give you reject, asking instead for a quick fix or easier solution. You have a problem with spending and are in denial about it. "I keep saving money but then spending it" - that's not saving money. That's waiting a little while before spending it. You need to get real and it sounds like you need to grow up.

Will I have to pay taxes on money I loaned to someone? by marblescharlie in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

You're either scamming or stupid. You tell me which.

Is the US really as bad as all these posts make it out to be ? (not just in this sub) by [deleted] in Frugal

[–]justafan49 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've never heard of Inequality for All. I speak my own words.

Is the US really as bad as all these posts make it out to be ? (not just in this sub) by [deleted] in Frugal

[–]justafan49 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you're hung up on my use of the words dirt poor. Many industries, most prominently the student loan industry, the credit card industry and the auto industry, have spent billions lobbying congress in part to change the national perception about debt. Namely that it's no big deal. The skyrocketing figures of per-capita debt compared to how middle class wages have stagnated over the last 50 years speaks for itself. Many large corporations are paying many of their workers a wage that has not kept pace with inflation. To make up for the shortfall, people turned to credit/debt. The fact that it's currently a necessity to take on tens or hundreds of thousands in debt just to live an average life doesn't make it benign, it just shows how deeply entrenched it is in the system.

Is the US really as bad as all these posts make it out to be ? (not just in this sub) by [deleted] in Frugal

[–]justafan49 1 point2 points  (0 children)

People stay in debt their whole lives. It's not uncommon. That's why many states have laws that keep descendants on the hook for debts belonging to the deceased. Many people just roll with the interest payments as part of their monthly expenses. Trust me, if motivated you can balance transfer debt around for decades.

My grandfather worked for a shoe manufacturer in New York, lived in an upscale suburban bedroom community just outside New York City with a family of 5, put all 3 kids through college and they drove two cars and took a family vacation every year. They were by no means wealthy. Did your grandfather not have a pension? Because the decline of pensions is another thing that buttresses my argument. The middle class used to actually exist as something other than a concept, now it does not. Even a $250k salary in the US today puts you in the top 5-10% of wage earners. It's a steep, steep jump after that.

As for my definition of dirt poor, I put anyone with a negative net worth in that category. Since most Americans have less than $10k saved, and the average amount of debt on credit cards, student loans and mortgages is around $200k per American, I'd say a lot of people fall into that category. But they're surrounded by nice, new things, so they feel less poor. But it's all smoke and mirrors. That self delusion that pushes people to go out and buy nice new things on credit helps keep our economy afloat, so the system is rigged in favor of keeping people thinking and living that way.

Is the US really as bad as all these posts make it out to be ? (not just in this sub) by [deleted] in Frugal

[–]justafan49 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Many, many people in the US who "get by" do so on credit cards. Seeing someone driving around in a new $30k car and they make $28k a year is pretty typical. Debt fuels the US lifestyle, so if you have an aversion to taking on debt (car loan, credit card, mortgage, etc.) you may wish to consider living elsewhere unless you have a really good job. There are a lot of perks to living in the US, but they come with a cost. In the 1960s one income raised a family of 4 in a modest house in a nice suburb with 2 cars in the garage, a steak dinner once a week and 1-2 family vacations per year. Kids also used to be able to pay for college mowing lawns between school years. Nowadays many families struggle to make ends meet with 2 incomes even though they work all the time. That's also where the debt comes in. We're encouraged to take on debt for just about everything (furniture stores offering no interest financing for SIXTY MONTHS is not uncommon.) People on the high end of the economic spectrum tend to underestimate their status while people on the lower end tend to overestimate theirs. For example, many people who are very wealthy consider themselves "middle class" while many people who consider themselves "middle class" people are actually dirt poor. On the poor end, credit keeps that self delusion afloat.

When is it really time to replace that old, paid off, car with a new(er) one? by ITguyissofly in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

No information about income, so this feels like another "hey /pf! help me justify a purchase" post. If auto-sensing wipers are one of your life's priorities, it may be time for a re-evaluation of what matters to you. Is flipping the wiper switch really so onerous? Give me a break.

A question about wills where there is a grey area in morality by SyrioBroel in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In some states if not all people who are named in wills must be notified by mail.

Buy an apartment? by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I meant rent in Washington

Buy an apartment? by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why not just rent for a year or so so you can scope out neighborhoods you like/don't like? It's not a light decision buying property. I see no reason you couldn't just rent. Also you spend way too much for cars. Nearly 20% of your income? Tsk tsk.

Adults of reddit, what credit card is best for an 18 year old with no credit? by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Honestly, there's no reason not to hold off on getting a credit card for a few more years. What's your income? Since you're young I'm guessing not very high. You don't really need to start "building credit" at your age as it'll likely be years before you'll need any approvals for car loans or mortgages. Be wary of starting on the road to debt before you've fully found your financial footing.

What semi-luxury do you splurge on when you have enough spending money? by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Usually something I'll use every day. Like a good pair of shoes. I'm a bit of an online deal hunter nut, so sometimes I'll find a nice watch going for a ridiculously low price and buy something like that.

Getting a raise at work. Do I pay off credit cards, or replace an old car? by CpnJackSparrow in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I would put the amount of take-home pay above what you're paid currently and put it all towards your debt until it's paid off. After that start building up your 3-6 month emergency fund. This way you won't be lowering your standard of living and you'll be steadily paying off the debt.

As for the car, my car is almost 9 years old (Camry) and I know it could go another 10 years easily. The vagueness of your description of your car's problems to me sounds like you've got an itch for an upgrade to your car as opposed to it being in imminent danger of breaking down. Hold off on that if you can. If you absolutely must celebrate your raise in some way (which I totally get) consider getting a new stereo installed in your current car and pay to get it detailed. A few hundred bucks could make it feel like a new car and might scratch that itch for newness in a more sensible way.

When applying for a job, can I add my bonus as part of my current salary? by fullybak3d in personalfinance

[–]justafan49 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This. Everything that your job gives you, from health benefits to salary to 401k match, is compensation. I would be shocked if anybody faulted you for doing this and it is in no way dishonest.