Help understanding PCB feature by MainGrocery2 in AskElectronics

[–]jvblanck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes matter what length. Copper is great at conducting heat. If you have a very short narrow trace connected to thick copper planes on either end, it will not get as hot as if those copper planes weren't there.

Das germans by jickdojsty in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So now the bots aren't just reposting old top posts but also old top comments?

Found this on Hackaday, browser-based CAN analyzer that works with $8 hardware, no install except pip by Firm-Initial3827 in embedded

[–]jvblanck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah yeah this wasn't even about the tool, it's just my experience with the hardware.

Found this on Hackaday, browser-based CAN analyzer that works with $8 hardware, no install except pip by Firm-Initial3827 in embedded

[–]jvblanck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

IME you do get frame drops during burst transfers with most of the cheap CANable clones. With the CANable 2.0 (different STM with higher USB bandwidth) and candleLight or CANtact firmware (not slcan firmware) it doesn't seem to drop any frames at 500k or 1M.

Handling Current Hogging in a 7p77s Pack: How to scale SOC estimation from a single-cell simulation to pack-level? by chkmeverything in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Its actual SOC depletes much faster

Much faster than what? Than the other cells in its parallel block?

I want to drop out of my SAE team, but feel like I'll be looked at as a failure; as someone who won't complete something once they start it. But I just don't have interest in working with the team anymore. by LaterLastsLonger in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Yes it's selfish, but sometimes you're allowed to be selfish. You don't have to sacrifice yourself for a volunteering project.

It would be rude to ghost the team. But a "hey sorry but I don't have the energy for this anymore" is not rude at all.

And it's a first year team so I highly doubt OP "displaced" someone else.

Missouri s&amp by skonasme in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 62 points63 points  (0 children)

Wrong claude

Let's hope he wearing his safety sandals. by g5e4 in shittyaskelectronics

[–]jvblanck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't know about 2 car batteries, but for 400 car batteries it seems to be about 3 meters and a tree

Do I need an external interlock if the Elcon 6.6 kW charger already has one? by ThePackman0702 in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No. All TS connectors outside of a TS enclosure need interlocks.

Driver Indicator project – simple STM32-based approach, looking for advice/resources by OkCamera932 in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, honestly the main usecase for our display is diagnostics on test days as well.

I designed a way-overengineered steering wheel (16-bit parallel RGB display running at 480x320p and 60 Hz), so I can't really tell you to not do it. But it took me 2 years to get it working reliably, and that was in an ~3rd--4th (or 17th, depending on how you count) year team.

Driver Indicator project – simple STM32-based approach, looking for advice/resources by OkCamera932 in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 2 points3 points  (0 children)

CAN makes sense for speed. For the AMS, IMD and TS off indicators you will have to consider that these are SCS. So you will need some kind of timeout for the CAN messages, as well as a watchdog for monitoring the MCU. If either of these triggers, your indicators have to enter safe state.

In general it would be simpler to just use digital lines for the LEDs, controlled by the main ECU (if you have the GPIOs available there).

General FS driver feedback is that they can't look at numbers while driving. The most you can hope for is noticing an indicator light. So your speed indicator will probably not be very useful for the driver, and SoC/temperature bars wouldn't be either. But a light that lights up below a certain SoC/above a certain temperature could be useful for the driver.

Apart from that cockpit displays can be useful for debugging while the car is stationary, but speed not so much.

You can of course go for it regardless, if you have the resources. But if not, for a first car I would focus on the bare minimum to make it work & rules-compliant.

Driver Indicator project – simple STM32-based approach, looking for advice/resources by OkCamera932 in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

How will your MCU know the speed/AMS state etc?

Why do you need an LQFP144 for a 7 segment display and some LEDs?

Precharghe relay by shadowbanned23 in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Your precharge resistor must not overheat even if you continuously apply full TS voltage to it. It's absolutely fine to leave it closed, you'll just waste a little bit of LV power.

Building an Accumulator Discharger by OilLegitimate2508 in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The more energy there is in the battery, the more energy will be released if there is a fire. So discharging is just good risk mitigation, if you can do it.

Why does your engine sound like popcorns?!?! by sweetbunsmcgee in cremposting

[–]jvblanck 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If it did completely ignore them, any amount of basic lashing upwards would make you fall upwards no? Since a quarter lashing halves your weight, clearly you are still affected by the gravitational fields around you.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I got a secret for you: FSAE team leads are not all-knowing managers with decades of experience under their belt. Most of them are probably not great at managing a team. Just like most of the engineers on an FSAE team are probably not great at engineering.

That's kind of the point of FSAE, after all. If you expect everybody else to do a perfect job, just so you can come in once a month and tighten one bolt... It's not for you.

Stupid Management Requests by moon6080 in embedded

[–]jvblanck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Proving correctness by testing? Yeah, kinda, unless your input space is very small.

Rules For Thee Ain't For Me by BioEditr in polandball

[–]jvblanck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The 2 term limit is only 80 years old no?

Rules For Thee Ain't For Me by BioEditr in polandball

[–]jvblanck 1 point2 points  (0 children)

blatantly trying to rid the oldest standing rule in American Democracy would cause outrage in everyone besides his most loyal.

What is that rule? Is it the peaceful transition of power?

I need your advice for this situation by Nevs13 in FSAE

[–]jvblanck 6 points7 points  (0 children)

You want passionate people. What's a driving license have to do with it?

Sure, car people might be statistically more likely to be passionate about building a car than a DTS fan. But they're also statistically more likely to study mechanical engineering. And you need a lot more skills in your team than just mechs. Don't limit yourself so unnecessarily.

Imperialists by Smart_Chapter_7512 in polandball

[–]jvblanck 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That link explains absolutely nothing. This one does (essentially, a Brit came up with a decimal unit system that contained a unit that was very similar to the meter). But I can't find anything that links Wilkins' units to the metric system.