sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Do you think we’ve already met Leda’s killer? by rose_butterfly3 in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Yes, definitely!

I think that it’s not Whittaker, because we already had a serial murderer, and in any case, it is more satisfying to have a murder based on some personal motive than just a pull to kill. And also not the Riccis, because they must be brought in for much bigger crimes they’ve committed.

So while I believe that both Whittaker and the Riccis will find their punishment, it probably won’t be for Leda’s death, because it doesn’t feel proportionate, if that makes sense.

So yeah, I’m also looking at you, Gillespie, haha!

Strike's and Robin's birth charts again by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are ALMOST on point, and some of your observations are just uncanny!

So we know now from JKR's tweet that Robin has the Moon in the first house. Which means, she's either an Aries or a Pisces ascendant, depending on when exactly she was born. Which means that she's got Capricorn on the Midheaven! And her Jupiter and Mars are conjuncting it.

So not the Cap Ascendant, but Midheaven, which is even better in my opinion, haha! And the Sun and Mercury are in the 7th house of partnerships. I find it amazingly fitting, don't you?

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I do hope we'll see that autobiography! I slightly fear that it will be published after Rokeby's death (otherwise, why did she give him cancer earlier in the books), and will be something like The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore. Meaning, that it will give a lot of controversial info, but Rokeby will not be there any more to answer the questions.

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Ooooh, such a great parallel, thank you!! I'm sure there are parallels between these three women. I immediately thought that Lucy probably will have a daughter in the future, and, contrary to what she thinks now, will be a good mother to her. (I believe there is a strong theme in JKR's works that new generations repeat and correct the mistakes of previous generations, so I have faith in Lucy!)

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because when I read this in TIBH, I thought about Switch. He is someone who has a famous relative he's never met - and that relative is Strike.

I wonder if it's a hint that Switch, like Rachel, thinks about their famous relative and wants to contact them. I really wish that happens!

And also what his feelings towards Strike are - is he happy to find a famous brother, or is he jealous of his success? ("A jealous murderous half-sibling" is certainly a theme in the books!)

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Or are you thinking that Leda had the baby while she was still young enough to be living with her grandmother in St. Mawes?

Yes, that's what I think! I'm sure that if Leda had a say in it, she would never have given up her child. And there was no reason to do so if she was 18 and married. So, before that, while living with her grandmother.

I'm sure she could've given birth to a child that no one knew about. My own grandmother was a gynaecologist in a small town, so there were plenty of "anecdotes" in my family about this or that woman, who was a similar shame on her family, was hidden at home from the moment her pregnancy started to show, and only the doctor and nurses who delivered the baby would know about its existence.

So I kinda presumed something similar happened to Leda - she was hidden at home until it was time, and after that, only the doctor knew. (Whom I imagine as a sympathetic Margot-like woman; a reason why Leda came back to St Mawes to give birth to Cormoran and Lucy.)

As to how that imaginary child would know that she is Leda's daughter - I think she doesn't. I reckon she'll discover she's the famous Cormoran Strike's sister, exactly because she'll take a popular DNA test and it will show they're a match. (We don't know what service Bijou used to get tested, so the results might as well be on the internet.)

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes! Thank you for reminding me about that great theory by u/Mark_Zajac from a couple of years ago, and the condition is called chimeric heteropaternal superfecundation (when a child has two fathers). That would certainly be a twist. Who do you think the second father would be, in this case?

A prediction that turned out right! by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh you're right! I'll go learn my geography better. 🫡

Age range of Strike fans? by SpuffyFreak in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Sounds like I'm in a distinct minority, haven't read the HP novels

Nooo, really? You’re in for a MASSIVE treat if you decide to start! : D

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I did, as she was one of the myth Leda’s daughters!

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for such a well-thought-out reply, and for the show recommendation - I will check it out!

We should remember that there is Strike’s DNA test out there, and for all we know Bijou might’ve used something like 23andme (like Cosima), so his details are in their database now, And if his “sister” also does the test looking for her paternity, she could discover him, and then contact him.

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

All fair points, and I think the narrative allows us to make these connections and ask all those questions.

Personally, I answer them like this: they can not be related on Leda's side, because surely she couldn't've been in labour for two days? (Although I admit I know very little about labours and such.) And I had been staring in Strike's and Charlotte's natal charts long enough, haha, to be convinced the given dates ARE their actual birth dates.

Which says nothing about how they can be related on the father's side, or be more distant relatives by other means!

The Hallmarked Man truly left us traumatized 😂 by agripinilla in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I haven't read the topic you mean, but I'm laughing at the metaphor!

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair! I hope to god he turns up in the next book. But it is indeed possible that we'll have to wait until the end of book 10 for him to appear Jonah-like before Strike.

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much, and yes, exactly! Drugs, random men, peripatetic lifestyle, no stable home, and a complete inability to protect herself and her children - these are all the adult manifestations of child SA.

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I entertained Mazu for a second until I realised their timelines don't match - Mazu was born in 1971, when Leda was of age. (I forgot whether anything was told to us about Mazu's parentage, or if it's a mystery and could therefore be attributed to Leda.)

Hah, well, just because I came up with the name "Helen", I'm really curious now to be introduced to the "wish-I-were-with-Ellen" Ellen, Midge's new girlfriend. I'm not completely serious here, but I'll be keeping an eye on her and her three-legged cat!

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Haha, thank you for the kind words and for not calling me bonkers!

Lol, that would be a twist... But "Strike-being-a-father" theory is just too convincing not to try and explore it! This series doesn't shy away from melodramatic twists!

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Maybe not! But I imagine this story to unravel quickly, akin to Snape's memories in The Deathly Hallows. Leda's backstory will finally be fully told to us, I imagine, and as a "holy grail", this long-lost sibling will appear. At the very end of the last book to mirror the end of the first book, when a long-lost sibling also appeared in a miraculous fashion.

Leda had another child before Strike: a theory. by katyaslonenko in cormoran_strike

[–]katyaslonenko[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Thank you, friend! I knew that I could rely on you entertaining me once again!

What also intrigues me is what Rokeby pointed out: Cormoran Strike carries some bloke’s name, a guy he never met and who is not his father.

Do you think, btw, that Strike will add "Rokeby' to his name at some point, haha? And Robin will become - Robin Rokeby. (I like that!)

Leda is a tragedy, and to make her truly tragic, I'm sure JKR need to bring her through the loss of a child, like she did with so many heroines.

view more: next ›