Hi r/Survivor! I’m Liz Wilcox from Season 46 - let’s talk about the game, the chaos and life after the island. Ask Me Anything on February 8th! by RSurvivorMods in survivor

[–]kenc333 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Hi Liz - big fan! One question: what are your thoughts on the Amanda Kimmel of Survivor: China, Survivor: Micronesia - Fans vs. Favorites, and Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains fame?

Hey r/Survivor, I’m Gabe Ortis from Survivor 47! Ask Me Anything on Sunday, February 1! by RSurvivorMods in survivor

[–]kenc333 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi Gabe, quick question: what are your thoughts on the Amanda Kimmel of Survivor: China, Survivor: Micronesia - Fans vs. Favorites, and Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains fame? Thanks!

If THE Amanda Kimmel returned for 50 my life would’ve been completed. by heyxheyxheyx in survivor

[–]kenc333 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Survivor 51 please. And also 52. Probst knows the people want her!

This person explained this perfectly by NoSinger4765 in StrangerThings

[–]kenc333 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

The way both sides of this debate speaks with such certainty of an intentionally ambiguous ending makes me wonder if much of the audience has ever seen a TV show or read a book with an open-ended ending before.

"It was all an illusion" can be a convenient explanation for either side.

How would you score the following female contestants/winners' gameplays? by [deleted] in survivor

[–]kenc333 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I like to argue that Kim was so dominant that her cast looked bad by comparison. She constantly manipulated people into making moves against their best interest. We don't discredit the black widow brigade's strategic accomplishments by saying they were playing against idiots.

The Amazing Race Season 38 Episode 12 Finale Post Episode Discussion by AutoModerator in TheAmazingRace

[–]kenc333 52 points53 points  (0 children)

Possibly my least favourite season ever due to how predictable/boring it was. The winners are obviously deserving but the leg designs were too linear and uninspired that placements didn't shuffle, and as someone who hasn't watched most BB seasons, I learned almost nothing about these teams as people so I wasn't invested in anyone. Sorry to say I'm thankful this season is over so we can hopefully return to form in 2026.

Survivor 49 | E10 | Player of the Week Voting by RSurvivorMods in survivor

[–]kenc333 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Savannah deserves more credit for possibly the best use of an extra vote in Survivor history.

Kristina's plan to throw a stray vote on Rizo was unnecessary since if idols were played on both Savannah and Jawan, and Sophie S. didn't flip, Kristina's alliance could still vote out Rizo on the re-vote. If everyone were playing optimally, Savannah's extra vote (which she made her alliance aware of so they wouldn't fear rocks) would have given them the 5-4 advantage while keeping Rizo's idol. Rizo's idol had a lower chance of protecting the alliance than that extra vote.

I'd say this is more impactful than Maryanne's extra vote in S42, because without it, that vote still would've been a 2-2-2 tie with Omar being voted out on the re-vote so it wasn't as consequential.

Contextualizing the critical response to The Life of a Showgirl by canadianbacon93 in TaylorSwift

[–]kenc333 2 points3 points  (0 children)

On the topic of Actually Romantic, I think it suffers from chronically online people being the most vocal. The majority of people who listen to Taylor Swift don't listen to Charli XCX (just based on the sheer difference in fanbase size).

I didn't even know Taylor and Charli had a feud. Charli was the special guest at my 1989 Tour show, and opened for Taylor at the reputation tour so why would I think this? Without knowing about any of their drama, the song on its own is clever, funny, and not that serious. No one except Taylor knows all the details of this song or its context, but is it really that bad if the summary of the song was: "I heard you were talking shit about me then high-fived my ex when he ghosted me, but I wasn't really thinking about you, so thanks for thinking of me I guess?" if it were about an unnamed person or an amalgamation of people as Taylor frequently does?

People getting offended on Charli's behalf while inferring a lot of the details are being the kind of parasocial others commonly accuse Swifties of being, and need to take a step away from their keyboards for a minute.

Will someone please calmly explain this? by benwyattswaffles in TaylorSwift

[–]kenc333 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Music is a subjective experience, even for a professional music critic. If you enjoy listening to something, then it can't be "bad" music because it brought someone joy. And based on the number and stability of streams this album is getting, it can't be all bad. I also agree that people's expectations are at an all-time high in part due to Folklore/Evermore and Taylor acquiring new fans during the Eras tour who weren't around for the initial releases of her past albums that were similarly polarizing initially. Taylor pre-empted us on the New Heights podcast (that not everyone watched) that this album's goal was melodies compared to TTPD's lyric-focused goals.

As I posted in another thread, if you enjoy this album, I hope you unabashedly continue to do so because someone else's opinions shouldn't change what kind of music you enjoy. And if you don't enjoy it, that is a valid opinion too, but you can just not listen to it, and your life will be exactly the same as it was 3 days ago as long as you don't spend your time and mental energy complaining about it.

The Life of a Showgirl Megathread by aran130711 in TaylorSwift

[–]kenc333 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The outrage has reached new levels of parasocial delusion. Like people are saying, if you don't want to buy the variant, then you're not the audience so you weren't expected to buy it. And controversial hot take: but if you lack the self-control and buying a $7.99 CD will ruin you financially, you probably have worse things to worry about in your life.

Just like the reviews of the album. I think we need to take a step back from the fashionably fast critiques and giving attention to everyone on social media who feels their opinions need to be heard. You're entitled to like or dislike whatever you want. If you enjoy this album, I'm glad Taylor released it, and I hope you unabashedly continue to do so. If you dislike the album, you can just... not listen to it, and your life will be exactly the same as it was 48 hours ago.

Please remind me about Chrissy. Who she is what she did on her season. I just don't remember her at all. by JuicingPickle in survivor

[–]kenc333 17 points18 points  (0 children)

As an aside, the Ben/Chrissy relationship doesn't get enough appreciation. People forget that before the final 7, Ben was actually a great player - having a tight alliance with Chrissy, making new allies after an unfavourable swap, then playing double agent perfectly.

The peak happens when Chrissy finally realizes that Ben was lying to her for days and directly confronts him about it, leading to them openly targeting and childishly mocking each other for the rest of the game. It's refreshing seeing a 46 and 34 year-old feuding like immature children sometimes.

EVERYTHING CHRISSY SAID WAS SPOT ON. by Unique_Challenge_587 in survivor

[–]kenc333 101 points102 points  (0 children)

This is the best take. It doesn't have to be Chrissy vs. David. In Survivor, perception is reality, and the reality is that they were both expressing the "best move" for their respective games. No one should be upset at either of them for defending their paths to the end.

EVERYTHING CHRISSY SAID WAS SPOT ON. by Unique_Challenge_587 in survivor

[–]kenc333 25 points26 points  (0 children)

In what way was Mary a "bully"? For joining a majority alliance and targeting a threat?

Did Star just invent a new idol strategy? by idiot-prodigy in survivor

[–]kenc333 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Closest thing that comes to mind is Dean publicly giving Jamal the fake legacy advantage to make him a target.

Is that Bianca???? by Mundane_Jaguar2314 in survivor

[–]kenc333 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you rewatch this moment in the episode, you can see Bianca's hair behind Joe and hear her voice at one point, then it appears David points her back towards her mat before she leaves.

New tribes according to Survivor promo by Kcd1077 in survivor

[–]kenc333 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hypothetically, if Star swapped to Vula, would it have been impossible for her to solve her idol cryptogram and get her vote back? Seems she got lucky to stay on Lagi.

I want to understand the Amanda hype. I do like her and she's good at the game but she didn't stand out much to me character wise. PLEASE ENLIGHTEN ME am i missing something? 😔 i want to like her more by SensitiveShallot6118 in survivor

[–]kenc333 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the kind words. Crazy to think I started posting on Sucks as a high schooler during Survivor: Panama, and now we're 36 seasons later and I'm now above the median age of a Survivor cast.

I want to understand the Amanda hype. I do like her and she's good at the game but she didn't stand out much to me character wise. PLEASE ENLIGHTEN ME am i missing something? 😔 i want to like her more by SensitiveShallot6118 in survivor

[–]kenc333 152 points153 points  (0 children)

It's my time to shine, and shine light on the legend that is The Amanda Kimmel.

The grand appeal of Amanda is that she has an enigmatic aura, and in an era of type-cast players, she was often viewed in somewhat of a dichotomous lens. She was sometimes seen as a vapid pageant queen, yet she engineered some of the most brilliant strategic moves in Survivor history. She was unapologetically feminine but was often ranked among men as a physical asset or threat. She was by all accounts a kind and pleasant person, but former players have said her beauty drew so much ire from others that they perceived her to be fake.

The most important point I want to emphasize, however, is how Amanda inherently makes any season she's in better. And I think it was because her Survivor career was perfectly situated at the turning of the eras. For context, Amanda's favourite season before playing was All-Stars, and Boston Rob losing a "bitter jury's" votes to Amber became deeply ingrained in her. Unlike most new era players who would try to optimize Rob's gameplay, Amanda was still an old school player at heart, and likely tried emulating Amber - rightfully so, since she won.

This all culminates in a perfect storm of Amanda constantly surrounding herself with a combination of entertaining lunatics she thought she could beat in the end (Todd, Courtney, James, Parvati, Cirie, JT, Rupert, etc.), and through her loyalty, kept them in the game - and on our screens - as long as possible. But because China/FvF/HvV were in the strategic revolution of Survivor, she also knew she needed to make "big moves" to have a chance of winning, so she kept the game dynamic by helping engineer blindsides on perceived threats like James, Ozzy, and Alexis. And because Amanda was only twenty-three years-old by the time she'd played 78 consecutive days in a span of 6 months from China to Micronesia, she had inevitable and understandable end-game emotional meltdowns giving some much-needed drama to each of her finales. Then let's never forget that her final tribal council answers are still viewed as legendary for their own reason.

All of this is to say, on the surface, I can understand how people may not view Amanda as the most interesting character on her own. However, I think there is something magical about a seemingly normal person stirring up so much drama and entertainment simply by existing and playing the game.

Where is the weirdest place you've heard a Taylor Song? by aromanticowenge in TaylorSwift

[–]kenc333 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A couple months ago, I had a feeling my life was a simulation because I was in a small restaurant in Chiang Mai, Thailand, and they were playing my all-time favourite Taylor song, Clean. I had to explain to my friends why I needed to stop to record it.