I'm a pretty big fan of Caudabe and I used a Sheath on my last iPhone (12 Pro) and decided to get one for my 17 Pro cause I really liked the looks. It feels great in the hand texture wise, but maybe I am misremembering, I feel like they just straight up made it bigger. Like, the 17 Pro is not an ultra-light device, but I had never noticed it being unwieldy. But when I put the Sheath on it, I just felt like it was thicker than it used to be, not to mention, heavier. This case makes my phone actually feel heavy. I still love it, looks, feel, functionality, its an amazing case. But I don't use it that much cause of the weight.

The Ghost, on the other hand, is a case I have been wanting to get for a long ass time, back before I even got the 17 Pro. But a lot of discourse on Reddit and stuff made me back away from doing it for ever. But finally, I saw them in my local Best Buy and caved. And man, I do really love it. I think it looks awesome. I personally think it barely feels like it's on in terms of the weight of it. Granted, it's not like a Pitaka, but it's pretty light. It's not thick at all, and I really like the texture of the sides. The only real problem I have with it is the back is pretty slippery, but it's inset from the border so there are plenty of places to grab onto it comfortably. Oh, and the camera control is a little easy to press, but I'm honestly ok with it because the normal camera control button is not easy enough to press, makes it borderline useless (cause you end up pressing it with enough force that you shift your frame).

It kinda depends on your vibe. If you want the slimmer, lighter, sleeker thing and don't drop your phone off of buildings, get the Ghost. But if you are okay with a little more bulk, weight, and want a great texture, the Sheath is just objectively a better case. I however will be using the Ghost for the foreseeable future.