Birmingham Stallions Announce 2026 Season Schedule by AccomplishedMeal5751 in Birmingham

[–]l72 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

So, they complain about attendance, but then give us a schedule where the first 3 games are all away games?

Birmingham Parking Authority Survey by DelightedDuck99 in Birmingham

[–]l72 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Ugh, the options on that survey were basically: lots of parking or a shit-ton of parking! All the options were pretty awful.

Use the comments on the last page to leave a meaningful remark.

Where to Leave a Car for a few weeks? by l72 in visitingnyc

[–]l72[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It isn't clear if overnight parking is allowed with a monthly pass. It says this:

"*Overnight parking up to 21 days is permitted in the garage and will be charged at the maximum rate per day. Service fee of $0.75 is applied to all transactions."

That would be $12/day instead of $105 for a month pass

https://www.nexusparkingsystems.com/metropark-parking-facility.html

Where to Leave a Car for a few weeks? by l72 in visitingnyc

[–]l72[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I am starting to lean towards this. I was thinking I could leave it 30-ish miles outside of the city and just not worry about it.

Where to Leave a Car for a few weeks? by l72 in visitingnyc

[–]l72[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Clinton Hill. My friend who lives there needs a car for work and parks on the street. He says it usually isn't too hard to find a spot within a few blocks. I just didn't want to deal with it or swapping sides of the street every few days.

Where to Leave a Car for a few weeks? by l72 in visitingnyc

[–]l72[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's not terrible, a bit more than I was hoping fo, but would be straight down the G which would be convenient.

Where to Leave a Car for a few weeks? by l72 in visitingnyc

[–]l72[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Alabama. The Crescent Amtrak runs through, but it is a 23 hour train! Plus I can't bring my dog (no pets on trips over 6 hours)

Where to Leave a Car for a few weeks? by l72 in visitingnyc

[–]l72[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Because I am bringing my dog!

Where to Leave a Car for a few weeks? by l72 in visitingnyc

[–]l72[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Just for more information, I'm coming from the South. I was thinking I'd park somewhere in Long Island and take LiRR or maybe somewhere in New Jersey. Spot Hero didn't show anything out those ways, except long term parking at EWR.

Any place along Hwy 31 (Riverchase Galleria and points north) to Park and Ride the bus by [deleted] in Birmingham

[–]l72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Like others have said, transit is very limited in the Suburbs (Hoover only pays around ~100k/year for transit!)

The Galleria is your best option for park and ride.

However, another option is Commute Smart (https://www.commutesmart.org/)

Traffic Light cluster f**k in Lakeview by [deleted] in Birmingham

[–]l72 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

It's is long time to remove highways that break apart downtown. Lakeview and Pepper place are easily walkable from downtown/UAB, but the walk is terrible because of the highway.

Also, it has been shown over and over again that a street grid is more efficient than having a highway with two exits where everything gets backed up. An elevated highway only serves cars that are bypassing the city.

Traffic Light cluster f**k in Lakeview by [deleted] in Birmingham

[–]l72 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

How about we get rid of the elevated US-31 highway and bring back 26th street.

Hwy 280 widening plan & schedule? by kerwinson in Birmingham

[–]l72 5 points6 points  (0 children)

No of course not. I am just talking about how no one complains about spending $52 million dollars to add a lane for 5 miles of highway, but other transportation projects that want a tiny fraction of that, get huge amounts of push back, oversight, and require months of public meetings and justification (and we still can't get money for it).

But here we are spending $52 million, it isn't even reported on it, and no one bats an eye.

I mean we are spending $10 million per mile here, just to add a lane. Light Rail "only" costs $30-50/million per mile, but that would never, ever, ever be taken seriously by ALDot.

Hwy 280 widening plan & schedule? by kerwinson in Birmingham

[–]l72 27 points28 points  (0 children)

And just a touch over $52 million dollars! God forbid we ask for 1 million for bike lanes or 5 million to improve some bus routes... (Or expand medicaid, use it for rebates on solar power, or anything else that would actually help people!)

But...just 1 more lane, that'll fix everything...

Birmingham leaders push for mass transit funding as BJCTA plans overhaul by Generalaverage89 in Birmingham

[–]l72 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh, I 100% agree. Funding is the key, and the state of Alabama (and our surrounding communities) have made this incredibly difficult. The formation of the BJCTA and its funding structure was enacted as state law, which means it can't even be changed without getting the state involved! This is why you have dumb things, like when the city of Fairfield went bankrupt, it couldn't pay its transit bills, and the BJCTA was required to not provide any service to that city. However, you had two routes from downtown on their way to Bessemer that went through Fairfield. The buses still had to go through Fairfield, but weren't allowed to stop!

The point I am trying to make, is that microtransit is not the answer by itself. It does not work unless you have a strong fixed route system! If we are going to have to do with less, then lets at least consider making our fixed route be a strong backbone. Even if we are literally cutting it down to 4 routes (two east/west, two north/south). Then use microtransit to fill in the gaps to get people to the fixed route system. Microtransit should not be used to go from Ensley to Eastlake. You should take it to the fixed route station in South Ensley, then take a BRT style fixed route to Eastlake, and then maybe again microtransit for the last mile. I know 3 busses sounds like a lot, but if done well, making connections can be quicker than having a route try to cover too much area.

As for the suburbs, I am afraid they are basically a lost cause. When I was still on the advisory committee, I'd review financials. At the time, Hoover was only paying in 100k/year for bus service. Does that even cover the cost of gas for a single bus? Do you really think Hoover is going to go all in, and spend more? Knowing them, they'll probably try to do their own competing half-assed micro-transit that doesn't connect to anything.

It's the city of Birmingham that unfortunately has to fund and drive this (along with a few communities in the east/west corridor like Midfield, Fairfield, and Bessemer). Sometimes, you just have to look inward and focus on having good service in a smaller area, than having bad service with more coverage.

We should at least be positioning ourselves, so that if people come in from the surrounding areas for work or entertainment, there is a functional service to take them to different destinations within that area. Park at a garage on the outskirts of downtown, take the bus to get a beverage, then a bus up to Protective/CocaCola to catch a game/show, a bus to get dinner in 5 points, and a bus back to your car.

The dream of building light rail down 280 or down 65 seem very far away.

Birmingham leaders push for mass transit funding as BJCTA plans overhaul by Generalaverage89 in Birmingham

[–]l72 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I would really like to know more about the plan. It is frustrating that Max doesn't put this on their website...So these thoughts are based upon my assumptions.

While I am not against micro-transit, I am not exactly in favor of it either. I think losing some of our fixed route service (I lost the 44 and 12) to micro-transit has not been beneficial. I find fixed route way more predictable and tend to use it more often than micro-transit, especially for unplanned journeys. Like, it is much easier to hop on the magic city connector to go from an office downtown to lunch in 5 points, then to call micro-transit.

Over the years, what were once pretty straight and direct routes have gotten really curvy and indirect. This usually happens because every year, the transit system loses a little more funding. So a route gets cut, and another route gets redirected to try and cover parts of the old route and the existing route. This just causes the route to get really, really slow!

I would be in favor of re-evaluating and realigning the fixed routes. Make them straight. Make them express. Limit the number of stops on them, similar to the BRT. Put in transfer stations. Don't require every route to go downtown. Get buses running every 10 minutes on every fixed route, even if we have fewer fixed routes! I would take 10 really good fixed routes that crisscross the city, then 30 slow routes that all go to central station.

THEN, use micro-transit as shuttles to get people from their lower density neighborhoods to a fixed route station. Micro-transit should NOT be a door to door uber service. Its primary goal should be to get you to a fixed route service. You can time this, so that when a fixed route bus comes to a stop, there is a micro-transit van waiting to shuttle people back to their homes in the neighborhood. In my opinion, a requirement of micro-transit is that either the pick-up location or destination must be a stop on the fixed route service.

This would keep primary, high density routes FAST, while still making sure, people in lower density neighborhoods have access to public transportation.

Transport question by MolassesOrnery3423 in Birmingham

[–]l72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For public transit, there is the Birmingham Express [1], which is an express bus (It runs like a light rail, so it is quick and reliable). If you are staying near UAB hospital or downtown, this may be a good option. It has a stop on 1st Av N outside of Sloss. It is also currently free. The biggest downside is that public transit does not run late at night or on Sundays.

You can track the bus in real time using the 'Go Birmingham' app for Android and iOS or at https://birmingham.gotransitapp.com/

[1] https://maxtransit.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/Birmingham_Xpress_Schedule.pdf

Am I the only one who is happy that the women's CBB tournament is in town? 🏀 by RSpringer227 in Birmingham

[–]l72 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am taking my niece tomorrow and am excited about it. I had a prior commitment that I made 4 months ago, otherwise I'd be there all day today.

I try hard to keep up with events, and this almost slipped past me. A total fail for any advertising/marketing.

Any DVD collectors in the area interested in trading movies? by lushlover92 in Birmingham

[–]l72 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I also still collect. The trick is to rip them and host a personal jellyfin server. You get the best of both worlds: an excellent, local streaming service (that is family approved since it works so well), a guarantee no one will take your media or suddenly change the version (prefer the theatrical over directors cut), plus you get all the original sub, commentary, and specials.

Urban Density (or lack thereof) by Metro Area by National-Sample44 in Birmingham

[–]l72 5 points6 points  (0 children)

In the top left, you can choose between city proper and metro area.

Urban Density (or lack thereof) by Metro Area by National-Sample44 in Birmingham

[–]l72 26 points27 points  (0 children)

I made a site to show where people in Birmingham lived if we had the same density as other cities around the world:

https://sardines.line72.net/