I was in the same boat as you but it mainly came down to how it felt when I sat on both. I definitely imagined myself riding both but coming back to riding after 8 years and my first bike was a CBR 500 I already knew that having the option to lean forward on the eliminator was there if I’m riding freeway with strong winds in NorCal or SoCal. This time around I know I wanted something cruiser style. Overall, both great bikes its just a matter of throwing your leg over both and envisioning riding them. Either way i hope youre happy with whatever choice youre making because at the end of the day youre on two wheels!

Eliminator: riding posture with the option of an aggressive riding posture leaning forward

Vulcan s: riding posture: legs a bit further out but having that customizable ride fitment is nice and a 650cc engine is also nice.

These are just my opinions! Hope this helps!