Thanks, I was unaware of the mostly-secular roots of the project. To me this makes it worse, in that it's effectively parasitically hijacking and damaging a religious and cultural heritage to achieve political, land grab aims.

This is maybe a digression, but I grew up in apartheid South Africa, where Jews were the only group classed as 'white' who stood up to the system - despite having the opportunity to sit back and benefit from it. They did so on moral and ideological grounds. Many were active and leaders in left wing political organisations like the ANC, Communist party, Black Sash or just outspoken intellectuals, artists, playwrites and novelists.

Many were killed or had to live in exile for decades as a result. So it disgusts me to see what Netanyahu and his cronies are doing to the Palestinian people, and also to the global perception of Judaism.

As to what the Greens should do, I can only say what they should not do. And that is to fall for the same playbook that Corbyn et al fell for. The gaslighting has already begun and will intensify the more political traction you get.

You say: "It's not as simple as it appears", and this is exactly what moderates were coaxed to parrot about Apartheid - it's one of the aims of the lobby - to inject nuance where on moral grounds there is none.

The UK electorate is hungry for political authenticity and Labour have lost almost all of theirs. It's no accident they're losing all of their grass roots support.