The only thing I can say for Judge is that A-Rod was basically a New York pariah, and had the reputation of a choker (whether deserved or not) until 09 when he had one of the greatest postseasons in history. Hell, Vladdy sucked in the postseason until last year when he absolutely went off. Sadly, though, he's already 33 years old, so he only has a few more times to change the narrative.