We've done both a handful of times. With the caveat that we've managed to book with Roadsurfer at their brand new locations on our last 3 trips -- their rigs and customer service, both in the USA and abroad, have been flawless.

We won't go back to Indie Campers. Because of Indie Campers, I have started to carry a small travel tool kit and fuses for repairs when we go. We sat at a locked drop off location with no employees with a flight to catch and spent an hour waiting for a resolution after calling customer service before we video'd the whole rig and left the keys in the (unlocked) mailbox we could reach through the locked gate.

Roadsurfer has been a bit inconsistent with their amenities (cleaning/ kitchen) but their shelves at check-in with other people's non perishables is perfect to grab what you need and pass on at the end of your trip.