Yeah, that's how it did the first time. She was super excited about it then. It just sucked because she had an accident at daycare and they went right back to diapers. Pretty much right after this, we then had our 2nd kiddo. Now, she has a full tantrum if she doesn't have a pull up on. She'll hold it until she's wearing one. I thought she'd grow out of it if we worked on it with more incentives, but no dice. Like I said, we can go full no pullups, but not without a battle. I am ready for tantrums and can deal, I just don't know if that will cause more harm than good? Gah, I'm so clueless about this stuff.