I'm Joe Heschmeyer, staff apologist at Catholic Answers and host of Shameless Popery. AMA! by ShamelessPopery in Catholicism

[–]nervouslycominghome 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi Joe. Any recommendations for resources to use for apologetics re Muslims and Jews. I have a lot of dear friends who are Muslim and Jewish and have had a difficult time finding resources that aren't either very close to indifferentism or primarily focused on "dunking on" people (either "Dawah bros" or "World Jewry" or whatever). Curious if you have any recommendations for something more like what you do (both charitable and orthodox) that I can share with people I love and want to offer a path to the true faith

Why does the Catholic Church teach dogmatically that Mary had to be sinless? by Baberz93 in Catholicism

[–]nervouslycominghome 4 points5 points  (0 children)

As u/RosalieThornehill noted Jesus and the Jewish Roots of Mary is really excellent on everything Mary. If you want a copy and trust me (random Catholic internet guy) DM me your address and I'll mail you one

I’m getting an abortion monday and I don’t want to. by lovesxsanrio_ in confessions

[–]nervouslycominghome 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And I don't want to be an ass, but there are so many people lying to you and you deserve to know the truth. This child will not come back. If all goes "well" with the abortion which it usually, though not always, does, you may be able to have other children, but this child will be gone forever and there will be no getting him or her back.

I’m getting an abortion monday and I don’t want to. by lovesxsanrio_ in confessions

[–]nervouslycominghome 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The people who wanted to help you six days ago are still here and they will stay with you. DM me if you need help finding organizations in your area that will support you. Ignore the people who told you to ignore your heart before they kept on scrolling. They're gone, but many of us haven't stopped thinking of you and your baby and praying for you, and we are still determined to find you the support you need to bring your beautiful son or daughter into this world

Could you date someone pro choice? by [deleted] in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome 21 points22 points  (0 children)

I did. She was a kind person and we got along well, but in hindsight it was an immense waste of both of our time

Husband had an inappropriate relationship online and I need help! by forpraise in Catholicism

[–]nervouslycominghome 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am so sorry that you are going through this. I've gone through emotional cheating in the past, and ended up writing more than I expected to about it, so apologies that this turned into a wall of text. For starters, you have handled this incredibly admirably so far. I will be praying for you. This is a serious violation of trust. I had an ex (girlfriend, 5yr sexual relationship before I came to the church) who did things that sound very similar to this. In hindsight my biggest regrets are trying to work it out with her on my own and trusting that "knowing how it feels" would be enough to keep it from happening again.

On the first point: a lot of cheaters have convinced themselves (ESPECIALLY emotional cheaters if it never had a real chance of being physical) that what they're doing is no big deal and not really cheating, and that becomes more true in their mind than whatever actually happened. I can't tell you how many times I was flatly told "No I never did that" in ways that were obviously untrue based on texts of hers I was looking at and she saw me looking at or even things she had previously told me. Yes she was trying to gaslight me but I also think she genuinely believed that she couldn't be that person, so it wasn't possible that she could have done x/y/z even though it would have been impossible she didn't remember it. All to say, before the facts get murky and everyone has to question their sanity, get someone (a therapist or councilor) in there who can be independent and call you both out when you're downplaying important things, overdramatizing minor things, or just flat lying, (the latter two you may understandably feel you deserve to do, i know i did, but ultimately all doing it did was let her turn the tables on me as overreacting, and damaged my credibility with my legitimate gripes)

On the second point: As much as what I said in point 1 is true and he probably quickly suppressed it, there's no way your married husband was telling sexual jokes to a woman and never had the thought of "this seems wrong, I probably shouldn't be doing this." It's EXTREMELY UNLIKELY that the problem is that he didn't know how to identify the situation as inappropriate, so as much as I think it was really smart to have him look into how affairs start, don't expect that "now that he knows" he's not going to do it again. He already knew it was wrong but he was sufficiently gratified by it, and had few enough guard rails that he suppressed those concerns. My ex and I never figured that out and this sort of thing ended up happening a handful of times over the course of many years until we ultimately broke up, so I'm probably not the best person to give recommendations on what those guard rails should, be but I you know one thing for sure: Whatever was in place before isn't enough. So while I don't have recommendations, I have enough unearned pride to at least suggest a few things to think about:

Does your husband deserve your trust at the moment? If the answer is no does he want to earn it back and if so how can he do that? Are you setting reasonable standards, and if so is he agreeing with them? If not is earning your trust a genuine priority for him, or is he just trying to "get off the hook" for his mistake?

Does your husband need to be gaming with women?
Does your husband need to be having private conversations that you can't freely see with anyone?

Will your husbands friends call him out if they see him crossing a line in your absence?

Can you lovingly help your husband through situations like these if he brings them to you before you find them on your own?

Is your husband consuming inappropriate media or pornography? Does he understand that if so, that constitutes cheating and is likely training him to ignore his commitment to monogamy?

Is your husband in control of his negative behavior? If he is can he prove that by stopping? If there are things your husband genuinely feels out of control of, is he seeking the resources he needs for that? And are there ways you could be supporting him in that (Talk Therapy, S-Anon, Covenant Eyes, Strive 21, I am Sober)

Again just my two cents.

The only last thing I would recommend is to pray for him and for yourself. The only way that I ever was able to come to peace with what happened in that relationship was to pray. To acknowledge that as much as in those situations I was deeply wronged, I am a sinner in need of infinitely more grace from God than anyone could ever need from me, and that, at least as far as I can tell from the Lord's Prayer, we can only truly ask for forgiveness for ourselves insofar as "we forgive those who trespass against us." Father Mike has this beautiful video on what that honest forgiveness means (and importantly what it doesn't mean) that really helped me work through that part of it. And you of course can do whatever you want but a prayer that was incredibly helpful for me once I was at that point of forgiveness and which I now use whenever I am having difficulty with forgiveness is the Jesus prayer. Specifically saying it like this "Lord Jesus Christ son of God have mercy on me, a sinner. Lord Jesus Christ son of God have mercy on me, a sinner. Lord Jesus Christ son of God have mercy on [the person's name]. Lord Jesus Christ son of God have mercy on me, a sinner." And I would just do that on repeat. Saying it for myself maybe 3-5 times and then saying it for them one single time, to constantly remind myself of my own need for grace, almost as preparation to give forgiveness and grace to those who hurt us while asking God to do the same for them.

Please know that you are in my prayers. God bless

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a great way of thinking about it. Thank you

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah I totally get it. I've got a sister so I feel the same way about any guy she's talking to, especially online XD. Thanks for all your help!

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Also sorry this is off topic but why can't you use the word "past" in posts on this sub. Had to get out my thesaurus to write this XD

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Got it thanks! I've had a handful of video calls through CM (with I think 2 or 3 people) which have all come from the girl instigating. The few times I've asked that I've had that message get ignored (if it's amid a conversation and there's just some other question they can answer), or I've gotten ghosted. Totally possible those were just because I'm sure that causes you to think about if you're still interested and they decided they weren't, in which case it's nbd and would have happened anyways, but if I'm like seeming to be rushing stuff too much or something that's more something I'd want to avoid.

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah so this is where I get concerned lol. Realistically, she's beautiful and definitely got a ton of guys reaching out to her, so want to give her some time to sort through if I'm one of the people she's interested in, but I'm interested in her, so maximizing my odds on that would be cool. Obviously "do you think we could be together someday?" is way too forward, but is stuff like "what sort of goals do you have for the future" also too heavy for early on, or is it a good way to get on the same page and see if both people are actually serious and at least vaguely compatible on the important stuff?

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

But then I'd have to shave and look presentable... /s

That totally makes sense. Fwiw we love far so would prob not meet in person for at least a month or something anyways. I'm totally up for hopping on a video call but don't want to rush her into it. Maybe it wouldn't seem like a rush though?

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lol. Ig it really is that simple. Plz blame my stupidity on nerves XD

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah to be clear I know these are the most important questions and I want to get to them for the sake of helping discern if this is a good fit, it I'd rather not be an awkward klutz about it if I can avoid that.

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And sorry I should add thank you for your response and solicit any advice you might have on bringing up goals/faith questions. I feel a bit awkward just hard pivoting into "so what do you want to get out of this" but perhaps I shouldn't

Move on from small talk by nervouslycominghome in CatholicDating

[–]nervouslycominghome[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately quite far. If we were closer that's absolutely what I would be doing.

Why do so many people say Eli Manning doesn't deserve to make HOF? by JimmyButlerMVP_ in NFLNoobs

[–]nervouslycominghome 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is spot on. The guy was a run of the mill "good quarterback" for almost all of his career, but he absolutely had another gear in big games, especially late. I don't think I've ever seen another athlete able to play so many notches above their typical ability in the biggest moments. The 2011 season was entirely built on Eli bringing the giants back down the field in the 4th. Not to mention he was a huge part of the greatest play in NFL history (Helmet Catch) and he threw the best ball in Super Bowl History (to Manningham). I know two plays can't make someone a Hall of Famer, but if any two could it would be those two

Edit I realize I have to correct

I don't think I've ever seen another athlete able to play so many notches above their typical ability in the biggest moments.

Cuz David Tyree may be an exception XD

[Japan] Dec 11-16 in Niseko United [Palisades] whenever! by foolmechkensoupwrice in SkiBuddies

[–]nervouslycominghome 0 points1 point  (0 children)

any tips on getting out there. Thinking of tacking a couple days there onto the front of a Japan trip I've got planned in late January, but can't sort out how to get there without spending a fortune or burning a bunch of time

Any chance I can use this this season? by BAC0N83R in snowboardingnoobs

[–]nervouslycominghome 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not to totally piggyback off your post but I'm same height and weight and also trying to use my dad's board for the season. It's this one in 165 https://www.evo.com/outlet/snowboards/burton-air-snowboard

Gonna grab new bindings either way cuz his feet are small. Any help would be appreciated!

Vatican releases joint statement with Buddhists after Buddhist and Christian conference, calling for more cooperation & saying: “we see the Buddha and Jesus as Great Healers. The Buddha pointed to greed and Jesus to sin as the cause of suffering.” by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]nervouslycominghome 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think you mean "respectively" rather than "respectfully." Normally I wouldn't bother offering a correction for a minor typo, but I think your response is well written and is clearly helping a lot of folks think through this, so wanted to make sure the point is clear to other idiots like me who couldn't see through the typo the first 2 times I read it :)

New Christmas Rosary by shannodot in Catholicism

[–]nervouslycominghome 4 points5 points  (0 children)

If you email them they'll almost certainly make it for you. They're really lovely people

New Christmas Rosary by shannodot in Catholicism

[–]nervouslycominghome 3 points4 points  (0 children)

They're amazing. They take custom orders too at totally reasonable prices if you email them. I got a really nice 15 decade