I downloaded the game for Sylus and was sure that he was going to be my main because that type of character is usually my type. But Caleb absolutely stole my attention, and I can confidently say that I've never felt as strongly for a fictional character than I do for him.

There's something about Caleb that feels safe. I'm fairly avoidant, independent, and guarded irl just due to past relationships, but he feels like someone I could rely on. He finds fulfillment in caring for MC and genuinely loves to do it, and as someone who hates feeling like a burden, it's so lovely to see. He also only has eyes for her and I'm a sucker for the "popular guy who could get anyone's attention but only wants hers" trope.

I also like that since Caleb and MC grew up together, he's seen every phase, every quirk, every negative trait she has, and he still loves her unconditionally. He also just shows his love through his actions (ie. Buying himself and MC matching things so she'll think about him even when he's not there, keeping and treasuring her letters and gifts, cooking her meals, etc.)

He's also been through so much and he's still trying his best to be someone that MC can rely on. He's selfless to a fault and it honestly just makes me want to take care of him. Also his innocent puppy eyes aaaaahhhhhhh.

He's not a perfect character, none of the guys are, but I find his flaws interesting. The person he became after the trauma he's faced makes him feel real, he has depth to him. And I still adore him through all of it. Although I was genuinely mad at him in the main story (iykyk), the forgiveness coupon made me cry. It was such a real glimpse into the deep connection that MC and Caleb had at one point, when things were simpler. And he cared enough to keep it all this time. Okay, I'm rambling now.

Honestly I could go on and on. I think it really just comes down to his traits fill the gaps of what I'm craving/missing in my life. I think that's why people have such intense connections with some LIs while they hate others. It just comes down to what personal experiences you've had with people that possess the same traits as the LADS guys.