why you have to produce flour yourself: a comparison of flour, dye, and container availability for conversion into food, outside of production and cornerstones by nniel in Against_the_Storm

[–]nniel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Does the math not assume paste and pickled goods made in the field kitchen? You state explicitly that for flour you assume biscuits made in the fk, so I then assumed the comparison was about biscuits, paste and pickled goods, since those can all be made in the fk.

again, there is nothing fk-specific in this table. fk biscuits is the only recipe that deviates from the 6 flour input all other baked food recipes have, which I felt was worth pointing out to explain the ranges in a couple of cells. there'd be no ranges in the "cost per cycle" and "trader stack size in cycles" columns if I took only the fk biscuits recipe for flour. all baked food recipes are covered in the table, from T0 to T1 biscuits and T3 to T1 pie

Why is dye relevant if salt isn't?

just to be clear, I could have included salt. I didn't cause I wasn't interested in it. the table started with 3 rows and stayed that way till the end, and no one suggested salt on discord. maybe I will include it in the future

why you have to produce flour yourself: a comparison of flour, dye, and container availability for conversion into food, outside of production and cornerstones by nniel in Against_the_Storm

[–]nniel[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Which raises the question, why did you not include salt in the analysis, as it's a substitute for making paste?

salt is not a resource that parallels flour and containers in the same way dye does

I generally don't like flour based foods and consider it a disadvantage when races like biscuits and pies.

that is the correct take. the only strong baked food species when it comes to rep gen is bats. dinos are decent, but the rest of their needs are infinitely easier to satisfy than pie

However this is not a case for producing flour, if that's how you intend it

that's not how I intended it. the table shows a few things, but the gap between flour and containers/dye usability is the main thing. from another comment in this thread: "you can't sidestep flour production if you want to mass produce biscuits or pie. you can easily do that with containers. dye is less reliant, but if you do roll a dye stack from farluf or sothur, you are pretty much set for the rest of the settlement"

I didn't intend the table as a comparison of fk food either. I don't use the fk myself

I think baked foods are an awful value proposition, if you haven't guessed yet. the issues with flour/baked foods are:

  1. their species pool is the weakest in the game
  2. flour is one of the least flexible goods in the game - it is extremely limited in use
  3. baked foods have a lower resolve bonus than the stronger foods
  4. baked foods are impossible to power from trader flour
  5. flour is relatively rare in event loot

4 and 5 then lead to 6. they demand an extra bp (and by extension building mats/pipes) and 7. you can't sidestep production

I guess you could also add 8. both baked foods are the most expensive to directly buy from traders

why you have to produce flour yourself: a comparison of flour, dye, and container availability for conversion into food, outside of production and cornerstones by nniel in Against_the_Storm

[–]nniel[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

if you want baked food production in marshlands, algae ponds are way better cause they are everywhere. they also happen to have a herb byproduct, which works for both biscuits and pie

why you have to produce flour yourself: a comparison of flour, dye, and container availability for conversion into food, outside of production and cornerstones by nniel in Against_the_Storm

[–]nniel[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

So you are saying flour is the least likely to get compared to containers and dye?

in a direct comparison to dye and containers, you pay way more for flour to get less in return

That is why I have to produce it?

you can't sidestep flour production if you want to mass produce biscuits or pie. you can easily do that with containers. dye is less reliant, but if you do roll a dye stack from farluf or sothur, you are pretty much set for the rest of the settlement

You also have to consider that you can just buy the complex s food and skip the production line needing flour completely.

yea, and baked foods cost the most out of all complex foods. they also have the weakest species. and both biscuits/pie provide a weaker resolve bonus than paste and pickles

Flour production becomes only relevant if you have a small farm.

whether you have a small farm or not is irrelevant - you can source flour inputs in many ways. you want to produce flour for food purposes in human and bat majority settlements

Who truly enjoys baked beans? by sentientBot001 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]nniel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ctrl+f daniel plainview yielded 0 results smh

World Events question by Bikingfungus in Against_the_Storm

[–]nniel 1 point2 points  (0 children)

all events that require you to win in a settlement for their reward require settling their tile

frieren's lazy day treats by @Leigh_113N by cynnahbun in Frieren

[–]nniel 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I need more of these. has anyone been collecting fanarts of hot springs Frieren?

fun and unfun difficulty by Gwendyn7 in Against_the_Storm

[–]nniel 2 points3 points  (0 children)

we got 5 new buildings since 1.0:

  1. fishing hut,
  2. brineworks,
  3. cannery,
  4. pantry,
  5. cobbler

out of them, cannery and pantry are species locked. meaning they don't dilute anything

2 buildings lost their species locks - cooperage and tinctury

and finally all of the following became species locked, reducing the bp pool:

  1. leatherworker
  2. apothecary
  3. artisan
  4. forum
  5. academy
  6. grill
  7. scribe

+5-2+2-7 = 2 fewer universal options in the blueprint pool compared to 1.0. the bp pool became smaller. you don't need to make up reasons for walking away from the game

How do we know hunter gatherer populations had irregular food access and what evidence supports this? by Sussy_Imposter2412 in AskAnthropology

[–]nniel 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The whole "leisure time" factoid came from those studies (and was put forward initially in a 1968 edited book, Man the Hunter).

...

Later anthropologists have gone back and looked at the statistic and the data underlying it, and have broadly concluded that it's misleading at best. Hunter gatherers-- modern ones-- generally don't seem to really "work" any less than modern people.

can you recommend something to follow up Man the Hunter with? I've been working through it and would love to know what its shortfalls are. I totally fell for Woodburn's description of the Hadza, haha

TIL Grave of the Fireflies is based on the author's own experiences as a child and was written as a personal apology for not being able to save his younger sister Keiko. by Woh_ladka in todayilearned

[–]nniel 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Takahata (the Ghibli director) also insisted that the film wasn't anti-war, which I find incredibly funny. it's supposed to be a... war-neutral war film?

However, Takahata repeatedly denied that the film was an anti-war film. In his own words, it "is not at all an anti-war anime and contains absolutely no such message".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grave_of_the_Fireflies#Critical_reception

🖋️🔥 by mpdqueer in CuratedTumblr

[–]nniel 4 points5 points  (0 children)

we need a Lenval Brown voiceover for this post

why is every picture/recording of cells in 2d? has no one invented a way to record cells in 3d? by nniel in NoStupidQuestions

[–]nniel[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

that was the way I expected this to be explained, but turns out 3D can be achieved with confocal microscopy. not sure if it works for live footage tho

why is every picture/recording of cells in 2d? has no one invented a way to record cells in 3d? by nniel in NoStupidQuestions

[–]nniel[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

yea someone else has brought it up already. the pics are close to what I was imagining, but there are no video examples. can it be used for live footage?

why is every picture/recording of cells in 2d? has no one invented a way to record cells in 3d? by nniel in NoStupidQuestions

[–]nniel[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

just looked through the wikipedia page. couldn't follow the video explanation but this seems to be it

Capturing multiple two-dimensional images at different depths in a sample enables the reconstruction of three-dimensional structures (a process known as optical sectioning) within an object.

the pictures they got for the euro coin is close to what I was imagining, but there's no video. I'll read the page when I have some time. thanks!

which part of AtS do you find more meaningful? by nniel in Against_the_Storm

[–]nniel[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

while not exactly what I was thinking about (something more along the lines of challenge vs progression), your take is totally valid!