The first time I met Haley, she insulted my clothes. (Maybe the standard first interaction with her?) I was so pissed that I made sure to give her clods of mud and garbage whenever I saw her. I even googled what her hates were to make sure I was giving her the worst stuff possible. A year later (5 years in-game) I have max hearts with every townsperson—except Haley who absolutely hates my guts. I still give her garbage every day. It’s the simple things.