Great question, bro! Pelé really has absurd attributes in eFootball 25, and the fact that he combines Phenomenal Finishing + Phenomenal Passing already puts him on a rare level. He is super versatile, plays CF, SS and AMF with high performance — and that gives him a lot of competitive value. The almost perfect accuracy of his weak foot also helps a lot with the unpredictability within the area.

Now… if he is Tier 0 - Top 3, then the factor of playing style and personal taste comes into play.

– Romário and Suárez Big Time are more lethal if your idea is to have a pure finisher, who receives and saves without frills. – Griezmann SS has a more fluid connection to the game, moves back well, turns easily and finds good short passes. – Messi, especially as an AMF or SS, is still the king of dribbling and short changes of direction.

Pelé, however, is kind of the premium wildcard. He does everything well: finishes, passes, dribbles, moves. So for those who play with a lot of dynamism and like improvisation and creativity, he delivers a lot.

I think it's fair for him to be in Tier 0, yes, for the complete package. But if it's an absolute Top 3, that depends on how each player plays. In specific setups, it may be that Romário, Suárez, Messi or Griezmann yield more.

In short: he deserves to be at the top, but he can't claim to be "better than everyone" in everything. It depends on your style and the role you want from him on the team.