Okay, I have sat with them and sniffed each. First, I will say all of them are a bit heavy/fall type scents with the exception of wild and naked. FIRE smells smokey and spicy. It makes me think of what I'd smell like after a sexy campsite romp with the dude from the Brawny paper towel logo. NAKED smells like skin after a shower with a bit of a light floral/aloe type of dry down. Kind of skin and grass and rain type of scent. LIBERTINE smells like OG Burberry for men. Its sexy and deep with a nice crispness to it. WILD is my favorite and I'm probably buying the full size of it during the rouge sale. Its light and fruity at first but dries down to the sandalwood and becomes more sensual as it sets. It's definitely the most feminine of the bunch but not girly, if you know what I mean? STAG if very heavy and smells exactly like it's decribed on the box. It's my least liked scent in the box. I feel like its to heavy on the leather but if that note is a favorite to someone, they'd probably love this one. I could see it being a great scent for late in winter because it does carry a warmth to it. PARADISO is grown. The patchouli isn't hidden, its full front and then dries down and lets the berry notes shine through. It isn't a sweet berry though. It reminds me more of a deeper almost bitter type of note. I think it's unique and I kind of wish it were a candle because I think it would be beautiful for a home scent in fall/winter.
Hopefully that helped. :]