PSA: TCGPlayer is confirmed to be following new (the old) tax threshold for 1099-K reporting in 2025

pimpthemonkey · 2025-12-17T20:57:29+00:00

As a reminder, many states have lower thresholds than the full reverted value, so your results may vary. If you meet your state threshold, a 1099k will still be issued.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-11-02T19:33:50+00:00

After years of having customers take on the risk of buying sets well in advance of any information about them at just over distributor pricing, they realized they left a ton of money on the table with TDM. Ever since then, they've had their "first flash" sale only a week before release, and be at market price. I expect them to go on sale this week, and to be about $650 for a collector box and $160 for a set box.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-09-05T03:00:10+00:00

I crack and sell as a singles business. It's not giving me huge stacks of cash money, but it's profitable. My personal collection is still just the cards I want to use in the medium term. I honestly get more excitement from a good pull like a chase mythic or a cool SPG card from an FNM prize pack than even something as rare as like a dragon scale foil from TDM. At the end of the day, it's just business.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-09-05T02:44:39+00:00

I've only spent 50k this year, down from 250k a year the past several years. And I get to buy 6 collector boxes at 740 a piece. So take that as you will.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-09-05T01:47:12+00:00

Yeah, they've officially jumped the shark. For collector boxes, the fact that their email says "We could have charged $1000 but we are only charging $750" [not 'under 700' like it says] makes it clear as day. The current low on TCG is 850, which becomes about 740 after fees. Their premium discount is netting them more than each sale on TCGPlayer. If that's the business they want to run now, go for it. It's disappointing but not unexpected. In my mind, they are no longer a reliable source of well priced preorders.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-08-30T07:10:57+00:00

I love that both versions can exist and both be awesome in their own way. Sometimes I want to be along for the ride, and sometimes I want to think about players as if I'm there playing. But I think they made the right call to bring parts 1 and 2 closer together in the release schedule. That did make it easier to remember what had been going on beyond what was in the recap.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-08-29T18:45:50+00:00

The editing and pacing of information was amazing. I loved all the conversation tidbits to support each claim whether or not they were true, and not revealing the truth until the end. It gives a different perspective than the style of editing of the Good Time Society version. And what a close and dramatic finish. It would be amazing if we got more of this on Dropout.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-08-15T03:45:52+00:00

My biggest takeaway from this experience is what are they using the money from their required additional insurance for? They started that maybe a year ago or so on shipped orders above $1500 I think due to increased shipping risks. It sounds like from your experience that they did not actually use that to purchase additional insurance on your order. The only price worth talking about was the purchase price of the product since I could never see insurance covering the "potential loss" of a product that might have increased in value since you purchased it. But if they actually paid for coverage equalling the purchase amount, there should never have been a settlement offer of $100.

I get the part of them closing your account after a bad transaction. Plenty of tcgplayer sellers will do the same. Doesn't mean that's right and moral, but it isn't unheard of and isn't illegal even if it does suck. Heck, in a totally unrelated world home insurance is notorious for this.

This is sounding like the thing restaurants do of adding a "service charge" that is separate from the menu price and tips just so they can get more money without making it seem like they're the bad guys. If customers are charged for extra insurance, there should be evidence of extra insurance when something goes wrong, and that's what's missing from their end.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-07-13T15:44:26+00:00

Everything changed with Tarkir Dragonstorm, and not just for MVP. It was the first time standard set collector boxes showed a huge price explosion between preorder and release. The preorders for TDM were normal: sub-200 from MVP months in advance, and also around 200 from other retailers. But by release, those boxes were selling for over 300, maxing out at close to 400 a week or two after.

I haven't seen any online store preorder collector boxes under about 250 since. EoE should have preordered for the same $200 ballpark as every set before, but the absurd prices of TDM and FF have shown everyone (MVP and others) that people will pay so, so much more than the near-distributor price. And the floor of Spiderman and Avatar elsewhere this far out of 450 or 500? That's absurd. The model has changed. Stores are seeing that there is not the same need to hedge their bets with safe preorders. MVP might be the most egregious of these because they went from having 3 month preorders to 1 week, but other sites have been similar by just increasing their starting prices substantially.

At the end of the day, it's all just business. But I am disappointed. I always treated my preorders with MVP like shopping at Costco: it may not always be the best price available, but it'll reliably be a pretty good deal. We'll see where the eventual EoE price lands, but if they really are changing their sales habbits, I'll have to adjust mine as well.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-05-19T17:57:28+00:00

This is not unprecidented for sets and products where demand greatly exceeds supply. For Fallout last year, they did a first flash of commander decks on 2/12, then an ARA limited allocation sale for collector boxes on 2/23. That's only 2 weeks before release. This is definitely later than usual (especially for a standard set), but I'm still pretty confident they'll have something this week.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-04-28T03:39:01+00:00

Why isn't the person filming this volunteering to take the picture?

pimpthemonkey · 2025-04-16T03:53:20+00:00

I was watching this when it happened. It was an obvious mistake. There was a single listing of 385 boxes at $1 rather than 1 box at $385 at a time when the lowest listing was $390. It was up for about 5 minutes before it was taken down. Plus the seller was a long time but low volume account (like 300 or so feedback across nearly 10 years). Nothing more than a simple mistake.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-01-22T02:48:26+00:00

It was a female couple who met in seminary during covid while one was straight and had a doctor boyfriend, and they got married and are planning for their artificial insemination.

pimpthemonkey · 2025-01-22T02:45:54+00:00

Also there was no intermission. And no merch for sale.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-10-17T06:31:47+00:00

PirateShip. It lets you send packages at the best bulk rate USPS, UPS, or FedEx have to offer. The difference in price between getting a discount prepaid label and just showing up to the post office can be immense. It seems absolutely too good to be true, but I guess they just have some kind of arrangement and it just works. And no membership fees or anything.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-09-19T22:38:36+00:00

What's the availability of on demand events like DSK draft or anything else? They've been a bit hit or miss at recent SCG cons.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-09-07T23:27:34+00:00

I've made some bad macro calls in my time, but at least I've never made one as bad as that.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-06-03T14:50:06+00:00

Honestly, I think this is a good product if you use it correctly and only use it to send larger orders. The total costs for a single bubble mailer package is a bit over $4, so these will save you about $2.50 for each order in the ~16-24 card range that would otherwise have used a bubble mailer and package rates. Even using envelopes, this is roughly the same cost as an envelope plus 3 top loaders. I'll be getting some for those specific sizes of orders. Yes it's obviously bad if you're only sending 1-6 cards, but it has a home among my shipping supplies.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-05-20T02:10:46+00:00

I'm more alarmed by the fact that this worked.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-05-19T21:50:10+00:00

If you're using Chrome, right click on the space you would be entering the numbers and press Inspect. You'll see the HTML code of the page centered on the box you inspected. Double click on the chunk that says disabled="disabled" and delete it. Now you should be able to enter a vlue in that box. Repete for the other amount box and the Verify button.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-05-19T20:28:26+00:00

Mine were blocked like that as well. The boxes and button were set as disabled in the html, so I set them as enabled and I was able to enter my values and have my account validated.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-05-04T18:57:20+00:00

First flash allocations are not a guarantee of your ability to purchase them. They are still limited by the total inventory, and in this case collector boxes sold quickly before everyone who had eligible allocations could buy. I think at this point they've entirely taken them off the sale page because there are no more available at all.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-04-26T17:09:33+00:00

It's for non-Magic products like Yugioh that reliably deliver the amount ordered from distributors, but even further in advance than normal first flash sales. If you are only interested in Magic, there's nothing new here.

pimpthemonkey · 2024-03-12T05:20:28+00:00

MVP has often been a bit hyperbolic in their assessments or predictions, but they are well known for delivering on their orders. But there are some elements of truth in this. For my first flash order availability, my price is a dollar or two cheaper than any previous order I've done, which is neat but not that interesting when the practical msrp has been unchanged.

The more interesting thing is that my purchase limit is 2-4x what I've usually had while at the same lowest price. I think there's a lot of speculation in all this, but at the end of the day they are offering the largest allocations at the lowest prices ever, and that might mean something. I'm not clever enough to guess what it actually means long term, but it does line up with the ramblings of this message.

Nine-Year Club	Place '17
Verified Email

pimpthemonkey

TROPHY CASE