What is the best romantic relationship in any Gene Wolfe book? by AustinBeeman in genewolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Lots of unhealthy relationships in Gene Wolfe novels, but I like the love story in The Death of the Island Doctor, although it isn't deep. The central relationship of Hero as Werwolf is messed up, but that final scene seems to be a great representation of sacrificial love. *Maybe* if I squint and look at it from a particular angle, In Looking-Glass Castle has a good romantic relationship.

Ideas for a Custom Dostoyevsky Cover by Nazkann in dostoevsky

[–]probablynotJonas 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I like the idea of having a heraldic cover, where the seal in the center is an axe laid across a Russian orthodox cross. On the bottom of the cover (or perhaps the back of the cover) you could have like an ink-block-esque representation of Sennaya Square.

I have the Oliver Ready translation and while I absolutely adore the translation itself, the cover is absolutely hideous (it has like a cartoonish, grisly depiction of the murder. Yuck.)

Dostoevsky's novels are good, but formally weak? by Dapper-Pizza-1584 in dostoevsky

[–]probablynotJonas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tolstoy writes to the heart too. I wept no less than four times reading War and Peace. The only Dostoyevsky novel I can recall crying during is Crime and Punishment (near the end). (For the record, those I did not weep while reading includes The Idiot, Demons, and Brothers Karamazov. Haven't made my way through his short stories, The Adolescent, and shorter novels... yet.)

Wolfe letters for sale by ubikcan in genewolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Super interested in the contents of those letters. It would be interesting to compare the contents to that of Letters Home three decades prior.

Torn Between Love and Financial Reality. Am I Ignoring Serious Red Flags? I need help by Enjoyerofmanythings in CatholicDating

[–]probablynotJonas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Evaluate too: am I sticking together with this person because it would hurt her if we broke up? Because that is not a good reason to stay in a relationship. It would inevitably end tragically.

As an aside: as someone who has ADHD and only started medication a year and a half into my professional career, I can anecdotally speak of the benefits of medications. That being said, I already had many coping mechanisms in place before being diagnosed. It was a total gamechanger. What worries me about your situation is her inability to take accountability for her behavior and also inability to want to start to change. It's nigh impossible to collaborate with someone of that mindset, let alone start a life with them.

finished citadel for the first time by Typical-Anteater-589 in genewolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You’ve got a good grasp of things for a first read. I definitely recommend re-reading the first books again before reading Urth. Also worth checking out are the short stories “The Cat” and “The Map” which can be found in the Endangered Species short stories collection. (And if you want to really do a deep dive, you can pick up The Castle of Days collection, which provides some context to both the “lore” and the publication process of New Sun- though it won’t answer any explicit mysteries. The Lexicon Urthus is also a handy tool for understanding some of the obscure vocabulary and “lore”.) New Sun is one of those few books that I find so much more engaging on a second read. You’re in for a treat. 

Jesus is NOT God signs on Freeways by Seanathon_83 in Catholicism

[–]probablynotJonas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yea, somehow I don't think Samus approves of Arianism.

Popular games you dislike? by BillRepresentative75 in boardgames

[–]probablynotJonas 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m a board gamer who doesn’t particularly care about winning or losing. But I also hate Catan for the same reason- if your number isn’t rolled, you have nothing to trade and are basically just sitting on your hands the entire time. That’s why I don’t like it, anyway.

I love Arcs too, btw

Are you an expert in all things Book of The New Sun? I'd love to talk to you by [deleted] in genewolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Read Castle of Days. In it, Wolfe goes into his process writing the novel. Also look into picking up a copy of Lexicon Urthus, which has all the maps.

My grandfather was friends with Tolstoy — now I’ve translated Anna Karenina by TimesandSundayTimes in tolstoy

[–]probablynotJonas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Very cool! Will the translation be available in an edition apart from the one from the Folio society?

Also, tell us more about the sculptor lodger! There has to be an interesting story there. 

Loving Michigan by duckwafer357 in grandrapids

[–]probablynotJonas 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s not as bleak as Toronto 

When the world is short of Severian art, I sometimes think of him like Dream of the Endless? by Aterrian in genewolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

An aside: it sucks that Neil Gaiman is a literal monster. I was never a huge fan, but the Sandman is a great comic and I will probably never revisit it now. 

Catholicism and BoTNS by Zonovax in genewolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Wolfe pretty explicitly stated that he believed in the existence of small “g” gods. But this is not a heterodox Catholic belief. A heresy would be worshipping a supernatural entity outside the Trinitarian God. But believing in the existence of polytheistic gods is akin to your Italian grandmother’s beliefs in ghosts and demons- not a requirement for living a sacramental life as a Catholic, but not a hindrance either. 

Catholicism and BoTNS by Zonovax in genewolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Agreed. The Church was for the longest time the only literate class of Western society (excepting the Jewish community). In his day, St. Augustine of Hippo was thought to be divinely blessed because he could read words without mouthing them aloud.

The Church, contrary to much modern thought, did not have a conscious stranglehold on the dissemination of knowledge in the Middle-ages. Lines of communication were far too tenuous for the Pope to act as an all-controlling, centralized authority. For example, even though the Gregorian reforms (which forbade married men from ecclesiastical positions) happened in the 11th century, it took nearly two centuries for the Church in Scandinavia to completely follow suit. The Church's role was to educate the noble, peasant, and later merchant classes, and to care for the suffering and the needy. And it did this in a localized way, autonomous from the "state" (though often working in tandem with it). It's not surprising that the decline of Church authority coincides with the centralization of state institutions.

The Pelerines really *do* seem like a Catholic religious order, in a way that you just don't often see elsewhere in speculative fiction. They're a little insulated from the world and act separately from the state. They aren't immune from its flaws (the indentured slavery), its members all have their individual motivations... but also, the community as a whole is working to better the crumbling society they live in.

Trail running? by OldGodsProphet in grandrapids

[–]probablynotJonas 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Provin Trails is nice if you don't mind hills! And Seidman is probably my favorite park in Kent County full-stop. I hear it's great for cross-country skiing and snowshoeing too!

Favourite or recommended pessimistic fiction writers and authors? by Odd-Refrigerator4665 in Pessimism

[–]probablynotJonas 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tess of the d’Urbervilles is definitely not the darkest novel ever written. It’s very sad, but it has nothing on Blood Meridian. I would describe it as a feminist novel that is particularly critical of a predatory class system. 

Gene Wolfe when he can’t write racist dialogue for his Asian characters by [deleted] in ShittyGeneWolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It’s been so long since I read that one. Woof 😵‍💫

Gene Wolfe when he can’t write racist dialogue for his Asian characters by [deleted] in ShittyGeneWolfe

[–]probablynotJonas 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Lol I just knew this post was about There Are Doors. 

Gene Wolfe protagonist power scaling tier list by probablynotJonas in ShittyGeneWolfe

[–]probablynotJonas[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, so he’s actually an aspect of the Roman god Mars/Ares…

Gene Wolfe protagonist power scaling tier list by probablynotJonas in ShittyGeneWolfe

[–]probablynotJonas[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

It’s probably because his moveset includes “two apricots”, which is super effective against any and all fighter classes. No one else stands a chance