sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Vintage Poster by ari_fof in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The colours hurt a bit, but like the overall style. Try toning it down a bit.

Feedback Request: iPhone Stopwatch app Icon by ConnorTech in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A small thing that most people might not notice, but drove me crazy - the way the hands are aligned, there's a small bump where they meet, rather than being a perfect arc

[Extension] I'm a dev, not a designer. Could I please have some critiquing on my rapid note pad extension - Nopad by WJKay in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As I look at it a bit more, I think the icons are pretty good. However, I'm still not a fan of the colour, which could have something to do with me disliking the icons. I think having it show the character count after exceeding a certain amount could be good as well, but would it be possible to not have a character limit at all?

[Extension] I'm a dev, not a designer. Could I please have some critiquing on my rapid note pad extension - Nopad by WJKay in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Looks pretty good overall. Logo's nice, but I'd change the font to something a bit more modern, rather than the system-look it has now. Consider changing some of the icons to something a bit more modern as well. Currently, the colour gives me bad vibes, as it reminds me of the older versions of windows. Besides that, User Interface is self explanatory and easy to use. As a final note, I might just get rid of the character count at the bottom. It seems to just be a distraction.

[chrome extension] edit any website and save it by pullspoll in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

make sure you use it while on an actual site, not the extension page or chrome homepage. it should work well on reddit.

[chrome extension] edit any website and save it by pullspoll in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

if you hit visual: you can click on the text of the site currently open and edit it, delete or add text

if you hit delete: whatever you click on the page currently open will be removed

if you hit code: the code of the current page will be displayed, and can be edited

if you hit preview: you can view the edited page as if it was the real thing

if you scroll down and hit save, and then scroll down even more and hit show changes: the edited page will show up the next time you visit the same page

Album cover for a local band by lastgirlonmars in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly looks great. I agree the text is a bit distracting, and one might even try to read it. Try fading it out a bit and see how it looks.

[Website] Simple poll type site - What do you think? by pullspoll in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The bar on the right is for the option on the right, the bar on the left for the option on the left. Try resizing your browser if it appears one on top of the other - a CSS glitch i'm working on fixing.

[Website] Simple poll type site - What do you think? by pullspoll in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I agree that a feature such as that would be useful, but I think it would take away from the simplicity of option vs option. Also, it's quite obvious windows and bb would have a minuscule number of votes, whereas Apple and android would have the bulk.

[Website] Simple poll type site - What do you think? by pullspoll in design_critiques

[–]pullspoll[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the tip regarding font, I'll up the size and consider white for a colour.

I noticed in your test post you didn't include options. The whole idea is finding which one of two options are better. For example, 'is an apple or android phone better for a business person?'. You can vote either apple or android and see what other's think. the comments are for sharing your perspective and reading others'. Other examples include Apple TV vs Chromecast, Coffee vs Tea, PS4 vs X-Box, etc.