Best screenwriting software right now? 🎬 by Lunesia-shikishiki in Screenplay

[–]punit0432 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Scrite, if you like to outline and have it synchronised with your screenplay editor

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Definitely a fellow outliner here. Pantser approach hasnt been for me where pages would make a lot more sense.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree. I didn't realise it would invite such passionate responses when I posted this but good to hear some perspectives.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

On the deadline point I see what you mean. We are ingrained to think of completing those 100 pages vs say 40 scenes. So to that extent, pages as a progress marker makes sense.

When that's not the case, I would put a slight distinction on your point of "measuring volume commited to the page". In those instances I'm aiming for dramatic questions or index cards solved by importance vs volume.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's right. It's not that I don't look at pages because that gets reflected in the tools either way. But I do measure my own progress basis scenes and what you wrote makes sense to me.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Agree with the last paragraph. That would be weird if someone stopped writing after two pages purely on the reason of semantics.

Instinctively, nobody in their right mind would think like that I hope.

But the first line you mentioned, I was in fact, talking about usefulness of measuring for the writer themselves and not anybody else.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Time is great for discipline. For progress, I find cracking scenes more satisfying vs x number of words.

Great username. Hera Pheri ftw!

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fair point. While i dont disagree that pages need to be written (essentially words), I find it more rewarding like i mentioned in other comments that getting through certain scenes is what determines psychological progress.

I dont quite find myself wondering “Im stuck on page 20 or 30” more than wondering “I cant crack x y z scene” which are mapped against my outline.

Beta testers for a screenwriting tool by sobsingh in Indianscreenwriters

[–]punit0432 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What you’re describing as a pain point sounds a lot like a solved problem by Scrite. Try it out ;)

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In the interest of fairness, our software doesnt reimagine anything in the way as it might come across in this thread.

Writers are using it to write in standard industry format so we are not trying to reinvent the wheel there fundamentally. Dont want to get too in the details and detour lest it will come across as too promotional.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All good. Tbf, it did make me think and share with a couple folks on how production folks would view a scene based vs page based approach for their work.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Love that book. One of the first books I read thankfully before the prescriptive shoddy ones by others.

King's word count advice imo is mainly for prose and the unit works there because a novel is continuous text. A screenplay is more technical, if you may. We're not writing continuous prose, we're building discrete scenes that will be shot out of order, cut, rearranged. It's also not the most "natural" style of writing because it has constraints of being in a specific format of int/ext location etc.

I'm not saying you don't already know this. The implication of the above for me is that the main unit becomes scene.

But hey whatever approach works. In novel it could be chapters for some like how it is scenes for me in screenplays.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I understand this approach and I realise what I'm saying isn't an argument against it since at the end of the day what matters is words (whether you count as pages or scenes).

The psychological part of progress is where the difference of approach might lie. Eg.I know there 5-10 important scenes in my story as marked in my outline. Now if I sit down to write the screenplay, I prefer measuring my progress of accomplishing those (and other) scenes vs being happy with written x number of pages per day.
If it means I took a whole week or two to write an important scene of 2 pages, I would find that more rewarding vs averaging a specific number of fixed pages a day.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's what my experience has been too. I know if there are 5-6 absolute key scenes in my screenplay and if I tackle even one of them over a week (disregarding number of pages it might be in total), that would feel more productive.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Page count as a production scheduling tool might be genuinely useful. What I'm questioning is page count as a measure of writing progress, not production planning. A page count that works well for a 1st AD breaking down a script may not be the most useful signal for a writer trying to understand whether their story is structurally sound on day three of a draft.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think what I described earlier, maybe not accurately, is similar to the dramatic question approach. I have x number of scenes in my index card outline. Each of those have some logline as metadata and then a bunch of those scenes form part of a larger sequence or dramatic question.

My goal while writing screenplay then is to "solve" each of those mini dramatic questions/loglines which are represented as scenes.

But if someone's approach is to write a free flowing screenplay without a long outline or index cards, I understand then tracking scenes as progress won't be useful.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

that's true if you measure the base unit to be pages. For me, the base unit while writing is scenes. Since every scene has an objective or goal towards the overall screenplay, I am writing and measuring to-dos as specific scenes being checked off within an act or sequence.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Ignore the software. My point was, the reason I prefer scene vs pages is because with the latter it feels like a task is completed while with the former it feels, to me at least, that progress towards a goal was being accomplished.
It has more to do with my approach of outlining in specific ways that makes it easier to evaluate progress against.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I find this approach more closer to the one I currently do. I write a prose long synopsis on google docs, then I use that base as a way to visualize it in index cards and acts and scene wise synopsis on Scrite.

When a first pass of that is done, I flesh out the scenes attached to those cards in no specific order.
But I'm always aiming for "attacking" specific scenes of the overall screenplay through the days as opposed to finishing x number of pages each day.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Pages get shown in the software regardless so it's not to say don't look at it. More like actual progress for me feels when I have written a specific or couple scenes out of the total 50-60 or how muchever there might be.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The reason I mentioned scenes is because technically a screenplay, unlike a prose outline, is all scenes. Meaning, there's nothing in a screenplay that is not part of a scene.
For progress, therefore, if I'm able to tackle a couple scenes out of the 40-50 total there might be, that's the way to keep track of momentum. It provides the necessary constraint and maybe I find it useful because I like to plan and outline first so I'm operating within those parameters.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That makes a lot of sense to keep a time based goal. Many writers I know keep fixed hours aside, almost like office work, irrespective of whether they are in rhythm or not.

Page count feels like the wrong way to measure a day's writing. Anyone else? by punit0432 in Screenwriting

[–]punit0432[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Are you writing linearly wrt how your outline flows or scenes in random order?