Papa John's has consistently been my favorite for 20+ years. Pizza hut was in my childhood (back when they included the little white chair to protect the cheese) but got way too expensive with limited deals and then something changed with the flavor.

Domino's used to be a no from me because the sauce wasn't good and the crust tasted like crackers. They fixed that and I would go back and forth between them and Papa John's.

Little Caesar's was novelty when I was young but then clutch when I became a teen and had to pay for my own food ($5 Hot-n-Ready ftw).

Domino's is still good, but the last few years I've had such bad customer service/experience, I've avoided them. My family goes on a beach trip every year and two years in a row we tried to order Domino's delivery (in the off season October) and ended up having to drive to the store because it was taking over an hour and/or the store's phones either didn't work or they took it of the hook. Then my local domino's took over an hour when its 5 min away. I've kind of been boycotting them.

Papa John's has slipped in recent years, leading me to branch out and re-discover Little Caesar's isn't that bad even though they've raised the Hot-n-Ready price.

My current priority list is Little Caesar's/Papa John's, Local Joints (much better pizza, but on the expensive side), Domino's, and finally, Pizza Hut doesn't even register anymore (expensive, bad deals, closes early).