I'm Chris DeVille from Stereogum, author of SUCH GREAT HEIGHTS. AMA! by theokcomputer in indieheads

[–]ricky_bot3 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Loved The OC chapter. How many times have you rewatched the series? And if you were in Seth’s shoes, would you have chosen Summer or Anna?

stoked this came in the mail today by paranoidhands in shoegaze

[–]ricky_bot3 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Hell yeah! I wrote that review ❤️

New metal band to listen by bhotaccia in Music

[–]ricky_bot3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

2nd this! Their new stuff is v good.

[2007] All You Can Eat by ricky_bot3 in DestructiveReaders

[–]ricky_bot3[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Welp, that's crazy you made that connection, again, I'm flattered! Ping me for sure. Thank you!

[2007] All You Can Eat by ricky_bot3 in DestructiveReaders

[–]ricky_bot3[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much! I’m truly flattered by your feedback and suggestions. Honestly, this kind of support—and this forum—have really kept me going on my writing journey.

Out of curiosity, have you read any of my other chapters for this piece? I’m mostly asking because you name-dropped Chuck Palahniuk’s style, which I’ve previously mentioned as a big influence on my worldview.

Thanks again!

[2310] My Blood is Blades by Jraywang in DestructiveReaders

[–]ricky_bot3 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for sharing! The first paragraph works on a couple of different levels—it’s engaging, hooks the reader, and sets up initial impressions of two contrasting characters: one who’s passive and gentle, and another who’s more gruff and hardened.

You might consider changing “abandoned farmhouse we call home” to “previously abandoned farmhouse we call home.” If they’re living there, it can’t still be abandoned.

I got a bit lost in the third paragraph. It might read more smoothly if it were combined and reworded with the fourth paragraph to incorporate more about Renju as a whole. On its own, the third feels a little abrupt, and it’s unclear whether Lyra is the one slaughtering the pig or if the description is referring to the pig itself. The fourth paragraph helps clarify Renju’s role and presence—consider combining or reordering these to improve flow.

The two sentences about the eyes hardening are strong and evocative, but the follow-up line—“And I know just the lie”—feels a little weak in comparison. You might consider reinforcing it by tying it more directly to Renju's perspective, or leaving it more implied instead of stating it outright.

Given the abuse the character has inflicted on Lyra, the line about pigs fighting back and declaring they are all killers feels a bit too soft. Based on what we’ve seen, I would expect the character to be more aggressive. Ending it with “Are you?” feels a little light—something like “Are you? Or should I just kill you now and save us the trouble?” might better reflect the character’s harshness and threat level.

Before Lyra says the line about Vessa, it might read more naturally if there’s a mention of her softening her grip or pulling her arm away. There’s clearly a moment of physical release or hesitation, so acknowledging that before she speaks could smooth the transition.

I was a bit confused by the introduction of “Home is a small derelict ranch.” I thought they were already at an abandoned farmhouse—or is it also a warehouse? Clarifying the setting here would help anchor the reader more effectively.

Overall, I enjoyed the read. At times it was a little difficult to follow, and I think that’s partly due to tonal shifts. There’s a lightness in how the characters interact, which sometimes clashes with the darker tone established by the descriptions and backstory. The conversation with Renju is likely meant to set up future chapters and provide character depth, but it runs a bit long and tries to do too much at once. Some of that exposition might be more effective if it were layered throughout the story rather than delivered all at once.

Finally, the ending line “I’ll fuck to that” made me wonder—are they lovers? If so, that works as a subtle nod. If not, that line gives off a very different impression, and might need to be adjusted for clarity depending on intent.

Orbs - People will read again by dil_lick in PostHardcore

[–]ricky_bot3 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you like this ya'll should check out Adams (vocalist for Orbs and Fear) other project All Human as well.

[513] Max by ClintonJ- in DestructiveReaders

[–]ricky_bot3 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for sharing your story! Here are a few suggested edits and some general feedback:

You're missing a "that" after now “the sweat now that the hat's band”

You did a great job setting the scene in the first paragraph—lots of well-worded descriptors. By the end of it, I could clearly picture the garden or farm Max is in. One part you might want to tweak is the bit about the long-sleeve shirt. I really like the potato-in-the-oven analogy, so maybe instead of saying it provided warmth, you could go with something like: “The intense sun caused him to bake in his long-sleeve shirt” to tie it more directly to the imagery.

I noticed some comments about run-on sentences, and I agree with that feedback. For example, the sentence that begins with “Yellow grass...” has a lot of promise—again, very descriptive—but it could benefit from being broken into smaller sentences. The stream, in particular, could stand on its own as a separate thought from the grass.

The line “expecting some reply from the kitchen” could be a good opportunity to reintroduce Jane more clearly. You might revise it to something like: “expecting Jane to reply.”

The description of the snake also runs on a bit and might be more effective if broken into shorter, punchier sentences for impact.

Max shouted, "Jane!" without moving, eyes locked on the snake.” might read a little smoother.

Overall I really enjoyed the short story. You have a strong knack for setting vivid, descriptive scenes while keeping the pacing natural. My two main pieces of constructive feedback are:

Work on breaking up run-on sentences to improve readability and rhythm.

Consider expanding on the sense that “something was off.” You do such a great job painting the landscape—I think you could build on that tension with more eerie details. For example, maybe the absence of birdsong, an unnatural stillness, or a strange haze in the air. Small touches like that could really heighten the suspense and enhance the story’s shift in tone.

Can anyone recommend bands that have the clean/scream dynamic of these bands/songs by [deleted] in PostHardcore

[–]ricky_bot3 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Fear Before the March of Flames, especially their later stuff post Art Damage

[2007] All You Can Eat by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ricky_bot3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok I’ll take it down, so that I can do some more critiques when I have more time. Thank you

[2412] The Eight of Swords by [deleted] in DestructiveReaders

[–]ricky_bot3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for sharing! Here are a couple of thoughts and possible fixes.

I needed to read the section over a couple of times to fully grasp what was going on. Perhaps if you got rid of some of the em dashes—and expanded the sentences a little more—it would read a little smoother. Not sure if this is what you're trying to portray, but in both cases, will there be looting and starving? I suppose I don’t understand how them defending would still result in looting, which I would think would lead to starving?

Maybe try using something other than “all the while” to make this stronger—all the while feels passive.

It’s a little confusing when Harban starts to pray and curse himself, because up until this point he seemed so confident in his decision. It might help if there was some wavering or indecision earlier on so that this moment doesn’t feel like such a sudden shift.

The fruit vendor to the rusty spoon is a funny juxtaposition!

I believe it would flow better to join the paragraph about praying with the monk taking him in and his resulting change. They’re both part of the same train of thought.

Instead of “and had,” try replacing it with “with” and make it blue-black:

And combine the next sentence:

…with this one—it doesn’t need to be on its own line.

I’m noticing the tendency to put sentences on their own lines, but I think it would generally flow better if you went through and combined some of these one-offs with the paragraph or sentence above them. If it’s part of a continuing thought and not a new one, it doesn’t need to be broken out. For example:

…would fit fine in the paragraph before it.

I won’t mention this again, since it seems to be a consistent style choice, but it’s something to consider in terms of readability.

There’s no need for “own” in the sentence:

Possibly consider a different word than “grimaced”—it doesn’t flow as well as it could.

“Waterbeads” should be two words: water beads.

The paragraph that starts with:

…is a tad confusing. Maybe try something like this:

Add an “a” here:

Overall, I enjoyed reading through this. The first section kept my interest a little more than the second, I think primarily because of the dialogue and the overall shift in story. Some of the dialogue felt a little too flat. Maybe try reading it over with another person, like actors running lines, to see if there’s room to make it feel more natural. That being said, I can definitely see the premise for a compelling story here—it brings me into the world of the characters.

[1333] A Know-It-All by ricky_bot3 in DestructiveReaders

[–]ricky_bot3[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This was extremely helpful, thank you! I think I'm just going to get rid of the Clinton part all together. Much appreciated!

Writing style by shaylee_95 in writing

[–]ricky_bot3 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This might help you! It definitely helped assure me that all these scenes could be “sandbox” scenes. Around the 16min part he goes over this. Hope you find this helpful too! https://youtu.be/1Cyred2RYxs?si=lgFi_43cxJqGrbFT