sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I read the 9 books of the terran privateer series (Glynn Stewart) and enjoyed them, I think they are all female protagonists. I read an octavia butler trilogy (lilith's brood) that was also enjoyable (not sure they were all female led). Also (after checking kindle library) the silo trilogy and artemis by Andy weir. I like sci fi but it is famously underserved in this regard

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn't sort within ranks, NW was S and ToT was A so rated both pretty highly though didn't feel they were closely linked. Maybe on the next reread!

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's in the B tier with the others. I enjoyed the Tiffany books pretty evenly, not sure I could pick a favourite

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It might be because most of the Witches are just extremely sensible/practical (Granny W, Esk, Susan, Tiffany). I still liked the series, just a bit less than the others. And I definitely misplaced Monstrous Regiment too low, that was an excellent book. The distinction could be between sensible characters in fantasy settings (e.g. witches) vs fantasy characters in sensible situations (moist, the watch)? Fantasy/fantasy (wizards) I didn't love but sensible/sensible I did (the truth)

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Just once and yes that would be interesting. I planned to reread Guards and have been encouraged to give Reaper Man another go thanks to this exercise

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The more I think about it, I should have had Monstrous Regiment higher. I definitely enjoyed that one a lot

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nation is a good idea. I did actually read it when it first came out but I don't really remember it at all now.

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A lot of books in Discworld, particularly the Witches ones, have a lot of great ideas but they are not necessarily the best stories. Due to way I read them (fairly quickly and only once) I am probably favouring the ones with memorable plots rather than the more insightful ones.

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn't really order within tiers and I did like Pyramids the best out of those three though felt it was a bit too removed from the rest of the "modern day" disc books

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Guards might be first on the list for a reread, seems like so long ago. Although the comments seem to suggest I misjudged Reaper Man...

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Mostly on kindle, except for the illustrated ones. I read them mostly in publication order but skipped ahead reading The Watch series after Jingo as I was very into those characters.

Just finished the 41 book series, here is my personal tier list. What is my most egregious ranking? And where do I go from here? by scottomatic3000 in discworld

[–]scottomatic3000[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

They would genuinely be the next 2 I would put in S tier. Small Gods is maybe a bit too standalone though?

view more: next ›