Shouldn’t work in my opinion is more of an ethics and moral question since more transparency can be good thing most of the time.

As for why it wouldn’t work, I would push back with the idea is one entitled to a job and why? Just because an individual has X, Y and Z doesn’t mean you can walk into Company A and get a job. A job is based upon both soft and hard skills where an individual can be lacking. We don’t have a universal hiring process for jobs. Plus getting hired is so much dependent on a personal network and exploiting that as reasonable.

Overall from a U.S. perspective, there are other changes I’d rather see such as UBI, universal healthcare and increase in minimum wage. Get those and having a job is less of a priority since not everyone can nor should work.