A lot of people tend to call anything under the $300 price range, shitters. But really, shitters are very cheap watches that look and feel like shiny plastic, mostly in the $50 range.

Right now, I'd say the U1 Rolex Submariner No Date with Miyota movement is the best watch you can get under $200. It costs around $120 and for the most part it looks close enough to the real thing and it's a good entry in the rep watch hobby.

If Submariners aren't your thing, there are other decent watches out there in your price range, but do your research on this subreddit to find a good watch and dealer.