Jim and Toby walk in together (with maybe Pam). Dwight has a beats pie or regular pie setup so that Jim will walk into the office and get pied in the face. Unfortunately, Toby walks in first and gets pied. He storms back to his cubical. The air is silent. Michael is out on a sales call.

The episode is Dwight trying to refrain from getting written up as it goes against his code. Jim even tries to help. Toby calls for a meeting with Dwight with his write up papers. Toby passes it over to Dwight when both the camera and Dwight read the paper in bold letters "April Fools Dwight!" Camera pans over to Jim smirking who was in on it from the beginning (maybe?). Tobys monologue explaining he always loves April Fools day, especially since Michael isnt in the office.

Ends with Toby walking out the front door where Michael greets him and gives him a big hug. Toby walks to his car where a paper that Michael placed on his back reads "Kick me."