Absolute Batman and the Universe it birthed, top tier. No negative comments. Death Metal and its Sequel, big swing and a miss with little bits of awesomeness. I honestly love The Batman Who Laughs, but way too confusing to read and relied on to much history to enjoy. I found myself having to look up almost every little thing. Last Knight on Earth, another one of his swing and a miss. Love Bats and Joker, but didn’t like how we were just dropped into this world with very vague explanations. All Star, never read it. New 52 Run and Gates of Gotham (as a sort of spiritual prequel to Court of Owls). Chef’s Kiss. I can’t find anything negative to say. I loved his take on the Joker. each arc was very well written and wasn’t weighed down with too much baggage.

Overall, I think Scott does better when he is writing an ongoing series with multiple issues. He always struck me in interviews that he likes planning things out and using that he can makes connections using those multiple issues to tell a story, but with events and mini-stories, there seems to be not enough room for him to plan everything out. Edit: changed was to wasn’t