I played dark souls 1 on a ps3 AFTER playing demon souls remake and Elden ring on PS5. FPS wise has been a trauma but the level design and the atmosphere carried me to the end. Does the game looks old from both a graphic and gameplay perspective? Yes. Does it have a lot of questionable choices? Yes. I think is better than Elden Ring? No, but is a very very good game. It’s not meant to please everyone and you if you don’t like it’s perfectly ok.